Zum Inhalt springen
omnism.si

Theravada · Diese Tradition mit einer anderen vergleichen

Martin Aylward: Dimensions of Consciousness - Manas, Citta & Vinyana

Martin Aylward · Gaia House (Devon) - Dharma Talks · 2026-09-30 · Newton Abbot · Quelle

Dieser Inhalt ist noch nicht ausgewertet.

Wortlaut anzeigen
Through the morning we've been evoking this quality of Buddha and this simple but not at all easy invitation to just rest in the fundamental awakeness of mind. And in the process, we see all the rest. We spoke about a little disparagingly this morning as a space junk. And that can seem a little discouraging maybe. But it's very much part of this process of not just awakening, which we sometimes imagine as being some kind of, if I can just get it right, an awake as if some kind of sudden significant radical shift in some way. And then everything will be easy. Then enlightened retirement. Actually, hence the term rather than using the term enlightenment or something that reinforces that sense of a kind of before and after sort of hinge moment. Awakening, awakening, awakening. It's an abiding in awakeness. So that a sense of the ways in which certainly there can be significant moments where we really see that fundamental luminosity of mind. Moments where we feel like, oh, there's just a resting in or a resting as that fundamental awakeness. And yet much of that process of awakening is also one of just becoming more and more familiar with this human experience, becoming more and more familiar with consciousness. So what is consciousness? Just see for yourself for a moment. What if I ask you that? What is consciousness? Where is consciousness? What is it that lets you know that you're conscious? These are really good questions. Really good questions. But they don't have really good answers. That's what makes them really good questions. Questions that just have answers aren't really good. They're quite limited. But questions that don't have easy answers or maybe any kind of definitive answers, oh, those are questions that can really open up. Questions that can really deepen. Questions that invite a response rather than an answer. So what is it to be conscious? We might see that tendency to want to find an answer. But rather we're inviting a response, the response of the question, what is it to be conscious? It's a way of just reminding us. Here we are. Here is consciousness. That's the best answer to the question where. Where is consciousness? Here. Pretty undeniably I would say. It's here. We tend to kind of rather clumsily, mistakenly, we tend to equate consciousness with living in our heads. That's partly because we've sort of inherited a materialistic model, a scientific model, a material model of reality. Not just inner reality and outer reality. We tend to measure it materially. We think about the building blocks of the universe. That's a material view as if the universe is made of stuff. And as if we can find those building blocks and so we, what are the small atoms? Oh, those seem to be, but apparently no, you can open up an atom. Most of what you find inside an atom is space. But then you get some other little things, electrons and protons. Not very good at this stuff. But if you open up an electron, I don't know how much they've been able to open up electrons or protons or whatever, most of what you find is space. You don't find the original building block. What's the original building block of a human? Is it atoms? Atoms don't seem to be particularly significant in my experience. I mean, you know, I'm sure that it's good that I've got some atoms, right? Millions or billions or trillions of atoms. Consciousness seems much more significant as that which underpins experience. And as I said, because we've got a kind of materialist education, we tend to equate consciousness with brain activity and with brain location. So most people, if you ask them, where's consciousness? Or a more ordinary way of asking, where's mind? We say, oh, it's in here. But it's not. If you open up your head, you will not find a mind. You'll find a brain, you'll find some gooey grey stuff that does some incredibly sophisticated job of zooming electrical circuits and things. But will you find mind? Will you find some long ticker tape of all the weird thoughts you've had today that you can... No, but sense apparatus is stuck on here. Eyes, ears. It's like all the data seems to come in here. So it's one of the reasons why consciousness seems so headbound. But actually when we relax and maybe you had that taste in meditation, maybe you had that taste this morning, sensing into a breathing body is that your mind in your head somehow reaching down and knowing that you're breathing. Sometimes it can feel like that because we tend to be heady. But actually if we really relax and open up the process and sort of enter a little more into meditation, no, it's much more the sense of actually our consciousness is in the breathing. It's inhabiting the breath. Or actually we might say that breathing is happening in consciousness. I know that sounds like a contradiction. One might say, well, is... Let me just see if you can track in your own experience. When you're sitting in meditation, is your consciousness in your breathing? Or are you breathing in consciousness? It's another good question. Buddha talks about awareness and experience blending like water and milk. If you blend water and milk, is the milk in the water or is the water in the milk? Well, they're blended. But that doesn't mean you can't experience it one way or the other. You're not wrong if you think the milk's in the water. You're not wrong if you think the water's in the milk. And it may happen that one of those just seems like a better fit. It's helpful in meditation to see which feels like a more obvious fit for you. A sense of really letting consciousness be inside the breathing. Or more a sense of the breathing happening within consciousness. Or maybe there's just that sense of blendedness. That sense of experience. And the awareness of experience are really unfolding in an inseparable way, showing up in an inseparable way. So where is consciousness? Here. Not here in a fixed way, not here in a way that we can say has edges, particularly or boundaries. Just here. If we turn our attention in that direction that we call inwards, what we find is consciousness. And all that's happening within consciousness. If we turn our attention outwards, seeing, hearing, what we find is actually consciousness. And what consciousness is revealing. Where is the seeing happening? We say, oh, I'm looking at something over there. It's totally okay as a description, but if we look more contemplatively, we might say, oh actually the seeing is happening here in consciousness. So consciousness pervades the sense of outer, just like it pervades the sense of inner. It pervades the sense of place, it pervades the sense of time. And we say, oh, I'm thinking about the future. Or I got lost in the past. No, you didn't. You can't go to the past. You might get lost in thought, but where is the thought of the past? It's here. Everything's here. That's very good news for a meditator. Everything's here. You don't need to go anywhere to find anything. It's also the way that a meditative practice genuinely gets integrated into all the other fields of life. Because fundamentally, there's really not much difference. We'll maybe speak about that later. There's really not much difference between being here in silence, on retreat, etc. And being here in work or at home, etc. It might seem, hold on, there's a lot of difference. You could enumerate all the differences. But I would say there are very small differences. We're moving at a slightly different speed. We're adding some more cognitive complexity. We're speaking, etc. But that's all kind of quite easily acquired skills. You already know how to move and how to speak, how to eat and how to rest. Whether you're moving slowly or whether you're moving quickly, whether you're moving quietly, or whether you're engaging noisily, most essentially you're here, right, in a consciousness that's revealing experience to you. And you're either caught up in what's happening through habit and fixation, or you're able to recognize and relax that fixation and now are more spacious abiding. Either way, here is where you're always at. And the more we see that, the more we're able to kind of trust here-ness. The more we're able to let go of a lot of there-ness. What's there-ness? The tendency to grasp after some other moment, some other place, some other possibility, as if we can really do anything elsewhere. But really fundamentally, there is no elsewhere. You've never been elsewhere, have you? How could you? The dream of elsewhere, the fixation on elsewhere, the image of elsewhere, the scenario about elsewhere, all of that's playing out here. So it doesn't have to be some kind of arcane or metaphysical or particularly subtle plane of experience for exploring. Actually in a very pragmatic way, in a very just real ordinary way, when we explore like this we start to just see the significance of learning to be where we are at, of opening up that which is here, of exploring the consciousness that's revealing everything. Buddha uses three different terms for consciousness which are helpful, right? I'm using the words mind and consciousness in somewhat vague ways, in ordinary ways, let's say. So let's try to be a little more refined about what we mean when we say consciousness. And not as any kind of intellectual exercise, but again please track in your own experience. The first term Buddha uses is manas, manas, it's the Pali word, and it really means the content of mind. This is what we're most familiar with. If you say to someone, what's your mind like? Mostly people will tell you about the content of mind in this moment, what they're thinking about or how they're feeling, or whatever the narrative is. So, my mind, I'm a bit tired or a bit stressed at the moment, or I'm feeling quite happy or whatever else. You could see for yourself what's your mind like in this moment and what comes to mind. Where does your interest, where does your perception go when you ask yourself, what's my mind like? So, manas is the way we most ordinarily and frequently experience mind. It's the content of mind, the discursive mind. And if we think of mind, as we talk about this little bit more as we go along, as a kind of this open space, right? This space wherein everything's happening, mind space, then the manas is the content. It's that which appears in the space of the mind. Think of mind as kind of the open sky of experience, or whatever happens in the bird song, birds that fly through the sky of awareness, or helicopters, some noisier things and less sweet ones than birds sometimes seem to clutter up the sky of awareness. The thought content, simple thoughts, but also more charged thoughts, thoughts that just seem like they're of not much use or relevance, thoughts that have a lot of charge to them, thoughts that are very familiar, thoughts that tell us all about ourselves and our history and our problems, etc. Or thoughts that are sweet, generous, tender, kind, loving, whatever the mind productions of the moment are, that's the stuff of manas. So when the Buddha is talking about manas, which we might translate as mind or consciousness, it's that it's the productions of consciousness, the content of consciousness. And that's what's playing out very much. Frequently we're our experience and our lives. Certainly the story we tell ourselves about our lives is dictated by the content of consciousness. And one of the things we're doing in meditation is learning to, rather than just believing everything we think, we're starting to recognize that there's a space in which thoughts are appearing and disappearing. There's a space in which each thought is an incredibly ephemeral, fleeting little blip. I thought, one of my teachers once said, it's just a tiny bit more than nothing at all. And yet, how much weight, how much authority we can give to any particular thought, particularly a thought about oneself. How much authority we can give to just a momentary judgmental thought. You know, you see, you see, you see, you see, you see, you see, you see, you see, you see oneself. How much authority we can give to just a momentary judgmental thought. You know, you're sitting here and there's some discomfort or some fatigue, and then just a thought about the discomfort. Oh, I don't like this. Or a thought about the fatigue or, if only I wasn't so tired, then I'd really be able to meditate. authority that we give to that thought the belief and then we add another one to it. Oh yeah it's really it's really not too much shouldn't have gone out the night before the retreat. It's true you probably shouldn't have gone out the night but just the adding their weight and then we're kind of getting deeper into the the thicket. In other words the Buddha used the thicket of views and opinions that we kind of concretizing thought giving it more and more authority believing in that rhetoric more and more and yet a lot of what a meditative practice is is we're kind of giving more attention not just to the content of mind but to the space around it the space in which the thought just arises does its little thing and then vanishes and in that sense you know actually thought is very much like birdsong. What a what a what a liberation really to see a thought as just a thought to recognize the nature of a thought as just a little bit more than nothing at all. Even if actually especially if it's a harsh thought a judgmental thought an unkind thought an unhelpful thought a self-defeating thought self-pitying thought comparing myself with somebody else thought the thoughts that make us feel miserable inadequate or self-aggrandizing thoughts thoughts that think that everybody else is inadequate actually very adequate. Those can be seductive in a different kind of way but actually similarly painful. You have to go down keep pumping oneself up it's a very fragile kind of brittle condition that's the condition poor old Mr. Trump suffers from. There's a kind of confidence kind of but it's so brittle so brittle maybe we can sense that in microcosm just the tendency just through the believing in a thought missing the fact that a thought is a little bit more than nothing at all being caught by the the momentum over decades of believing in similar thoughts to conceive of oneself in some kind of deficient way or a grandizing way or comparative way so we get a lot of opportunity in meditative practice to just see manas and to see thought productions mind productions whether those mind productions are more verbal stories or maybe they're more visual and kind of in a movie however they're playing out just that sense and maybe have had a strong sense of that or maybe just a glimpse of that even through the last 24 hours of the capacity to abide in or as the space in which thought comes and goes the capacity to not believe everything you think to be the awakeness that recognizes a thought another term the Buddha uses for consciousness then is chitta and chitta again often translated as mind or sometimes as heart there isn't really a distinction in the Buddhist tradition between mind and heart so it's a helpful distinction when we say mind we tend to mean that which is more cognitive and when we say heart we mean that which is more emotional and what those those share in common is the manas of the thought and the feeling life but then there's also the chitta chitta means consciousness as this space this what we call this open sky and the chitta is colored by the manas so if manas is the activity of consciousness mind productions chitta is the space of consciousness the mind scape the mind scape and when we say like earlier I was saying most fundamentally we're always here whereas here we're in the chitta sphere the chitta sphere the mind scape and that's you know that's very very helpful I found that very very very helpful to to really orientate to that that's where I am most primarily and secondarily I'm in Devon and I'm a guy house and I'm here and there and here and there it's not that we forget it's not that were you floating in oh where am I just in the mind scape and says the 415 to Newton Abbott no no he's perfectly able to function but you know it's like all of that like I say that's already acquired skill you totally you've got time and space down right decades ago you're not going to forget how to operate in time and space but what if time and space was not your primary coordinates what if the chitta sphere was the primary orientation here then when we ask what's your mind like rather than just looking at the productions of mind we sense into the chitta sphere spacious what's your mind like a spacious what's the coloring of mind right now oh it's bright or whatever it's kind of some sleepiness is a kind of flatness or this confusion I'm not really following the talk so we can believe in the stories is confusing I don't understand it what a waste of time or we can just oh yeah this is the chitta where there's a sort of a kind of shakiness or confusion chitta is always colored by something and knowing the way the mind scape is colored moment by moment being awake to the sort of the changing form that the inner atmosphere of experience again is liberating that which can recognize confusion isn't itself confused that which can feel into sadness isn't itself sad this is the way our practice opens up into a kind of fearlessness with experience a kind of that welcome that we spoke about yesterday sadness welcome there's nothing wrong with sadness confusion welcome in fact anything at all anger hatred happens to hatred if you welcome it because if you don't recognize it it takes the authority then we get fixated on the object of our hate and the reasons for our hate etc etc or anger or resentment or our jealousy or our blame but if we're able to all that's painful you know what's the how does the chitta sphere get colored by a moment of hatred the way the tension of it the poisonous feeling of it the kind of the annihilating wish of it the Darth Vader like certainty that I'm right and the other asshole is wrong flavor of it and if there's nothing that can't be welcomed into the open space the infinite sky of the chitta sphere and meditative practice just gives us the opportunity to just to keep reminding ourselves that that's where we are we're here in this mindscape we're here in the open sky of consciousness we're here witness to the changing colorings of mind and then the third term the Buddha uses for consciousness is vinyana vinyana that's refers to the the knowingness of consciousness so if the manas is all of stuff appearing in the sky of mind and the chitta is that sense the theater of experience the open sky with its different weather patterns colored by stormy weather or clear weather etc and it's like the vinyana is the sun that's just constantly illuminating the sky and sun seems to get obscured right because of clouds or whatever we sell the sun's gone in the sun's disappeared it's actually it's just just been covered over you know plenty of chance living in England to see how the sky can be covered over although seems like it's been a long hot summer here but you know that thing when you go if you take a flight and in on a gray day and how we even though we know it's still a surprise you know when you take off and you go through the clouds and then you emerge as pristine skies pristine and it's like that right with the sunlight of awareness we we in just the same way that we treat the Sun as if it comes and goes but it doesn't just the single constant in the unit in the solar system just there shining the same way we treat awareness like that we have a sense of it comes and goes I was aware then I wasn't aware now I'm trying to be more aware I'm trying to make awareness come back and of course we might speak like that in terms of our practice but again does it make a difference to orientate to this knowing us this wakefulness that we've been speaking ab