Zum Inhalt springen
omnism.si

Orthodox · Diese Tradition mit einer anderen vergleichen

Why the Most Difficult Prayer Cannot Be Commanded | 10@9 | 2026.11.15

Rabbi Michael Whitman · Rabbi Michael Whitman (ADATH Congregation, Montreal) - Mining The Riches Of The Parsha · 2026-11-15 · Montreal · Quelle

Dieser Inhalt ist noch nicht ausgewertet.

Wortlaut anzeigen
Good morning. Today is Sunday, November 15, 2026. At the end of last week's total portion that we read yesterday in Shul, told us, when Asav finds out that Yaakov took the brocha from Yitzchak that was intended for him, Asav, he was very, very upset and very angry. By his tone, Asav as Yaakov, al-ha-brocha, asher-berhu, Aviv, Asav was furious with Yaakov, for taking the brocha, the blessing from their father. Va-yomur Asav-el-ebo, Asav said to himself, Yikruvu, you may avil Avviy, when the time comes that my father will pass away, vahar-gos Yaakov-okhi, I'm going to kill my brother Yaakov. I'm not gonna do it while my father is alive, but once he's gone, I am going to murder Yaakov. Now the Torah says that he said it beliebo to himself, but obviously he said it loud enough to himself that other people heard. By Yugadlarivka, as Divre Asav, bin Agadol, Rivka found out that the intention of her older son, Asav, vatishla vatikrily Yaakov bin Akatan, and so she called her younger son Yaakov. Va-tomre love, and she said to him, Hine Asav-akhi-kha misnachem l'chalahar-gecha, Asav is planning to kill you. She wanted to warn Yaakov. V'ata, and she says to him a practical suggestion. V'ata b'nishma bakolid, now my son listened to what I'm saying. Va-kum barach lecha el-lavin-okhi-charana. Run away back to my brother's home, Lavan, which is in Charan. That's where the family originally came from. Then you'll go back there and you'll be safe from Asav. That is Rivka telling Yaakov. Then Va-ikra-yitzkakal Yaakov. Yitzkak called Yaakov, by Yomelo and said to him, among other things, kum lekpadena rom-beis abasula vie-mecha. Go run back to the house of your mother. Rivka basul her father, Lavan her brother. So both his mother and his father are telling Yaakov to run away back to where Rivka came from. And Rivka is explaining to him why. Va-ishma Yaakov el-aviv vel-emo. And Yaakov listened to his father and to his mother by Yelakpadena rom, and he ran away from where he was in Israel on his way to Padun Aram. That's last week's total portion. So Yaakov is running away from the threat of death at the hands of his brother Asav. And everyone understands that Asav, we may not, obviously, it's not the right thing to do, obviously, but we understand that there's a, it doesn't come from nowhere. Asav is very upset. And Asav, as we understand, is a person who is capable of this kind of violence. Now we begin our total portion. Va-ye tze Yaakov me ber-shovah, va-yeh-la-khar-onah. Yaakov leaves his home in Be'er-shovah, the southern part of Israel. Va-yeh-la-khar-onah, and he's on his way to Charon to Padun Aram to where Rivka's family is from. Va-yeh-ka-ba-makom. And he encountered the place. Our sages tell us the place refers to the place where later the base of M'gdaesh would be built. Yerushalayim, Jerusalem. Va-yeh-la-nshom. And he spent the night there. Kiva-ash-emesh, because it got dark. Va-yeh-ka-khmay abne-yam-makom. He took some stones from that place. Va-yeh-sa-mi-rash-osav. He placed them around himself. Va-yeh-shka-ba-makom-ahu. And he laid down and spent the night slept in that place. Va-yeh-halom. And he had a dream, famous dream. Vihine-sula, Mutsav-Artsah. There was a ladder that was resting on the ground, Varosh-a-Magi-ah-shemaimah. And the head of the top of the ladder reached heaven. Vihine-malakhe-alokim-olim-vyardim-bo. There were angels of God ascending and descending on this ladder. Va-yeh-ka-ba-makom. He encountered the place. The word makom is also a word that is used sometimes to refer to God. Our sages tell us in the Talmud, Mesakht-e-Brah-khos, when the Torah tells us, Va-yeh-ka-ba-makom, he encountered the makom ein-pigyeh-el-at-tfila. This encounter was an encounter of prayer. Yaakov prayed to God. This is the Rabbis' midrashic understanding of these words. Yaakov prayed to God. And our rabbis further say that with this prayer, Yaakov teakane tfila arvis. Yaakov established for all time the prayer of Marev, the evening prayer. It was nighttime, right? The sun had set. It was nighttime. Yaakov prayed. Yaakov established for all time the prayer of Arvis of Marev. Now we've discussed this before a number of times. Avram established the morning prayer, Shachris. Yitzchak established the afternoon prayer of Minchah. Yaakov established the nighttime prayer of Marev. And each one of them established it with their own mood and their own mode of prayer. And it's expressed in the Torah by the word that is used to describe their prayer. We discussed this before. Concerning Avram, it says Vayamod, Avraham stud. The word Amidah is the mode and the mood of Avraham's prayer in the morning. The prayer of Yitzchak is expressed with the words lasuach to converse. Lasuach pasadah. Siach is a conversation. That was the nature of Yitzchak's prayer in the afternoon. And Vayivka, the prayer that expresses Yaakov's prayer at night, is Pigea, an encounter. An encounter is different than a conversation. It's different than standing. And so let's explore briefly what is unique about Yaakov's prayer, how is it different than Avraham and Yitzchak, and what makes that unique about our prayer of Marev that we daven every night. The Gamara says the same passage of the Gamara. The Gamara says what is the source of prayer. We've discussed this passage also a number of times. What is the source of our prayers? So first the Talmud says the Avvos, our patriarchs, what I just shared with you. Avraham established morning prayer, Yitzchak established afternoon prayer, Yaakov established Marev. So we have three prayers. Of course, they didn't write the same words that we say. The words were written later on. But the fact that we have a prayer that we say in the morning and a prayer in the afternoon and the prayer at night, and the fact that our prayers mirror the mood and the mode of their prayers, that's what the Talmud says. That is the template of our prayers. Then the Gamara has a second approach. Our prayers are corresponding to the Karbanos, to the sacrifices that were offered when the base emigrants were standing in Jerusalem. We have discussed a number of times the connection between sacrifices and prayer, but this refers to the Karban Tumid, the daily offering when the base emigrants were standing. There would be one offering in the morning and one offering in the afternoon. So our prayers correspond to the Karbanos, the Karban Tumid. But the Talmud asks, how do we reconcile these two approaches? Because the first approach leads us to three prayers, Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov. They're three prayers. But if we ascribe the prayers, our prayers to the Karbanos, they're only two. One in the morning and one in the afternoon. So which is it? Is it two prayers or is it three prayers? So the Talmud says, Shachris and Mincha, the morning prayer and the afternoon prayer, Chhova. They are obligatory for all men who are required to observe the mitvahs that apply at specific times. Women have an obligation to pray, but they're not limited to a specific time. Any time of the day is fine for women, but men are obligated at specific times, a prayer in the morning and a prayer in the afternoon. That's an obligation. Are this the nighttime prayers? Rishush. It's voluntary. It doesn't have the same strength of origin because although it was established by Yaakov, it does not correspond to a sacrifice. And therefore it is voluntary. If you want to say ma'arav, you can say it. If you don't want to say it, you have something more important to do. Let's say you have a more important mitvah that has to be done at that time. You can omit ma'arav. Now, just in parentheses for a moment, that's what the Talmud says, and that's how it was originally during the time of the Talmud. However, through the practice of the Jewish people, through centuries and centuries of accepting upon ourselves to say the nighttime prayer of ma'arav, today it does have the status of a Chhova of an obligation. So for us, practically, there's no difference between the morning, afternoon, and evening prayer. We're required to say all three. But the origin of it is that, again, originally, it was Rishush. It was voluntary, not obligatory. The normal way that we understand this, excuse me one second. I forgot to turn off my phone. I apologize. The normal way we understand this is that therefore ma'arav is a little bit less important than the other two prayers. The other two prayers, you got to do it. But ma'arav is voluntary. If you want to, yes. If you don't want to, not. So it's a little bit less important than the other two prayers. That is the normal way that I think most people understand it. But Rabbi Norman Lamb wrote that the contrary is true. Ma'arav is actually more important than Shachris or Mincha. Rabbi Lamb quotes Rabbi Yitzchak Meir Alter. He was the first Gerer Rabbi. He was the author of a very important work, a Hasidic work called Khidush-e-Harim. He was born in 1799. He died in 1866, a very important Hasidic master and teacher. And this is his insight into the prayer of Ma'arav. What Yaakov did in establishing this prayer at night. And let's remember the context of Yaakov's prayer, where he was, where he was going, why he was going there, what was happening to him. What Yaakov established that was unique is that Yaakov established for all time, for all descendants of Yaakov, the entire Jewish people, the ability, the strength to retain hope in the darkness of night. What Yaakov did was to pray to God in the most somber and gloomy and the blackest of circumstances. And what Yaakov did in establishing this prayer for us is that for us now and for all time, a Jew can and ought to achieve a sense of security through prayer. That's how Rabbi Lamb explains the Gerer Rabbi. That's the nature of Vayivka, the encounter that Yaakov had with God, this ability to retain hope in the deepest darkness, in the gloomiest and most somber of times to retain hope through prayer. Rabbi Lamb concludes from this that Ma'arav is not less important because it is voluntary. That does not indicate that it's less important. On the contrary, he writes, Ma'arav is more precious than Shachris or Mincha, more difficult and more demanding, for it is a far greater challenge to hold your own, to keep the faith even when the sun has set, even when it is dark all about, when you are beset by danger, when you are fleeing an asof and you are preparing for a leaven alone and hungry and frightened. That's the unique character of Ma'arav that Yaakov establishes. And Rabbi Lamb writes it's for this reason that Tfilas Arvis Rishus, that this nighttime prayer is a voluntary prayer, not because it is any less important. On the contrary, it is more important, but it's voluntary, not obligatory, because one cannot legislate heroism as obligatory. What it takes to be able to, Da'avim Ma'arav, to be able to encounter God at night when things are difficult, when we're vulnerable, when we face danger, that heroism cannot be commanded, required. It is rather a privilege, a unique strength to be able to know of the coming dawn when the sun has already set, to know that through prayer we can retain our optimism and hope, even in the most dire circumstances. That's the uniqueness of the prayer of Ma'arav. It's voluntary, not because it is less important, but because of the level of heroism it calls for, cannot be commanded. It has to come from the inner strength of a person. And that inner strength we receive from Yaakov, who is the first to exhibit it. We see today, as we have seen for centuries, innumerable instances of Jewish heroism, innumerable Jews who, in their darkest moments, engage voluntarily in heroic actions, in heroic lives, certain that with our Pigea mode of prayer, our encounter with God, certain in the coming of the dawn. Rabbi Lamb shared this insight in 1975 and the heroism to which he referred then is, if anything, more applicable to us today. Because Rabbi Lamb ends this essay with the following. At the end of this week's Torah portion of Vayetse, after Yaakov has lived with Lavan for over 20 years and married his wives and raised his family and had to deal with all the trickery and deceit of Lavan over all this time, the Torah tells us, Vayomer Hashem el Yaakov, God appears to Yaakov and says to Yaakov, it's time for you to return to the land of your ancestors, to the land of your fathers, your mothers. Ulamolat etetekha, it's time for you to return to the land of your birth to go back to Israel. Remember, he'd been away all this time. God says to him, it's time for you to return and then God adds, the E'e'eimach and I will be with you. Arabis and the Medrish comment on these words, it's time for you, Yaakov, to return to the land of your fathers, the land of your birth. And Arabis add these words, it's time for you to return to the land of your fathers, the land of your mothers, the land of your birth because your father is waiting for you. Remember, Yaakov left his father and his mother and he was to return to them when the danger passed and God says to him, the danger has passed. It's time for you to return, Avicha matzapelach, your father is waiting for you. E'e'eimach matzapelach, your mother is waiting for you. And God says, Aniba atzmi, I, God, matzapelach, I'm waiting for you in Israel. My friends, I wish you a great day and I look forward to seeing you soon in person.