Tonglen Behind Bars
Dieser Inhalt ist noch nicht ausgewertet.
Wortlaut anzeigen
Thank you for listening to UPIA's Dharma podcast, an extraordinary series of talks from some of the finest teachers in the world. I'm Joan Halifax, founder of the UPIA's End Center, and we're happy to make these podcasts available to you. Please consider making a donation so we can offer these recordings freely. You'll find a donation button on our podcast page. And thank you so much. This is DharmaPodcast at DharmaPodcast.org. This is episode number 2688. It was recorded on November 11th, 2026. And it is titled, Tonglin Behind Bars. The speaker for this episode is Tuck Stibich. Can everyone hear me okay? It's good? Great. Welcome. Thank you so much for coming. It's wonderful to see so many people. I'd like to start just as we do with gratitude. I like to think about how strange and impossible this moment is that we're all just here gathered together. And so many people, kind of so much effort, so many people come together to make this moment possible. So thank you to Roshi, to the teachers, to the residents, to Amy, my partner for all her support. It's just, yeah, wonderful to be here with you all. Thank you. Thank you for coming. I'd like to start with just acknowledging that it's Veterans Day, November 11th. And probably about an hour ago or so, I got, there was an email from our friend Wendy Johnson. And she was reminding us that this day is November 11th, 1922, was why we celebrate Veterans Day on a day. And that's Armistice Day. So it's a day of peace. And Kodo did a little research. And it is, yeah, so it's November 11th. And at 11 a.m., they rang 11 bells to signify peace. For the places that still had bells that hadn't been melted down into weapons. And then Wendy also linked it to Kurt Vonnegut, who was a veteran, who was a PWO. And he wrote in his book, Breakfast of Champions, that to him it was Armistice Day that was sacred, a celebration of peace. And that's what mattered most. So I thought we could begin today by ringing our large bell, which did not get melted down in Japan. It's come all the way 11 times. And as this rings, just think about the vibrations and maybe join with those vibrations going out, calling for peace. So yesterday, I was at Clayton Prison along, and that's in Northeastern New Mexico, about a three hour drive. I was there with Jane, I don't think she's here today, who is amazing and has spent years and years volunteering inside and Todd. And we were there for a sangha that had formed. And it's amazing, like the sangha formed in the midst of this kind of crazy, insane, harmful system, this toxic prison system that they're there. And it's a system that harms everyone who touches it. It harms the correctional officers, it harms the chaplains, it harms the volunteers. And yet in the midst of that, these men came together and created a Buddhist sangha. And they actually reached out to us. They had their moms write us. And so we got letters from their moms and we couldn't resist. And so we're helping them, we're working with them, we're coming alongside them. And there's that group, there's some other groups too, and I'm gonna kind of combine them in what I'm talking about. And what amazes me is that what brought them in, it was a moment. And I think about moments in my own life, moments of anger, moments when I mess up. And the consequences aren't that high, because the conditions around my life are really supportive. But for them, when they were younger, and a lot of them have already been in ten years, they've got 20, 30 more years, some of them are lifers. There was a moment when something went wrong. But the conditions around them had drugs, had alcohol, had people struggling with anger. And often had a gun. And in that moment, something goes tragically wrong. And then they're inside, ten years later, 12 years later, not the same person they were then. And inside is this concentration of kind of a violence in a way. Recently there was a lockdown. One of the prisoners was upset because this piece of cake was smaller than the rest. When all you have is a piece of cake, that's a big deal. And he brought it up to a guard and he said, what's going on? You know, my piece of cake is small. And the guard said, don't be a crybaby. Go away. And he says this in front of, so it's escalating, right? So he says this in front of the other prisoners. And so that prisoner feels he has to do something. He pushes the guard. The guard falls, heads his head on concrete. He's out for like six minutes. The whole thing escalates. Everything's on this like just edge of a moment. And yet we have this beautiful group that forms and their intentions are to figure out how to show up in the world, in their world that they're in, to learn what they can. So there's these causes and conditions and these moments that happen. And this kind of reminded me of some teachings or she's been teaching lately and her writing of these two concepts of Zinke and Uji. Undivided activity and being time. So Zinke is this idea that Dogen talks about that each moment, each being, each activity is expressing all of reality. It's complete in itself. There's nothing held back, nothing missing, nothing waiting, nothing outside. Every moment the whole universe is functioning together. And Uji is this idea of being time. Dogen's not saying, he's saying kind of, we don't exist in time, but we're in this, we're not like a container flowing through time, but we actually are time. You are time, I am time. This flower is time. The prisoner is time, the guard is time. And she writes about this, or she writes about this in her forthcoming book. And I'm gonna read a few paragraphs because they really, for me, shape how what's happening in the prison. She says, of all of our institutions, none has built itself so explicitly on a theory of time as the prison. When we speak of it, metaphysics allowed without hearing ourselves. Wait, this is a person, sorry, our speech manifests this. A convicted person does time, serves time, is given a sentence measured out in years. As a time where a substance, the state could confiscate. The way it confiscates a weapon. Punishment is a seizure of a person's hour. And the doctrine is colder still. The confiscate at time, it's as if the confiscate at time was worth little anyway. The man in the cell has no present worth living, no future worth protecting. The men live most of them in a temporal condition the institute has designed for them, pure waiting. Waiting for the count, for Chow, for the parole board, for the years to grind path. Waiting is the experience of time as an enemy, a dead weight to be gotten through. The prison manufactures it deliberately because a man who experiences his own hours is worthless, is easier to manage. And then she says, some of those men sit Zazen. And something happens that no security classification anticipated. One man told me after many months of practice that sitting in the circle was the only part of the week in which he was not waiting. He discovered without a word of Japanese what Dogen meant, the present moment cannot be incarcerated. The walls cannot take his decades. They cannot take the entirety of the world that as Dogen insists is present in each moment of being time. Nguji says his hours cannot be confiscated because it is not a portion of some larger quantity that the state is holding on its behalf. Each hour is the entire world. And then Zinke says something else. In the hour he's actually living, nothing is missing and nothing stands outside, including himself. And then she cautions, I must be careful because there's a sentimental reading of this that I must refuse. The fact that a man can realize being time inside a cage does not justify the cage and indites it. If every moment of being is the entire world, then a 30 year sentence is not the subtraction of an abstract quantity called duration. It is the attempted confiscation of 30 years of entire worlds. What those men realized on their cushions was not that prison didn't matter. It was that the prison had been lying to them about what they were made of. They were not doing time. They were time doing. And this has really struck me thinking about what is it like to have a moment, 10, 12 years in the past, having that play out for 30 years, 40 years. And again, the groups just, they kind of blow me away. They are asking, they show up for our classes for anything they can do to improve themselves. They want to become better for others. Perhaps it's for a child they see only occasionally on visitation days. Our spouse, our other insiders. And some even extend that to the correctional officers. They say that if they can reduce the stress for the correctional officers just a bit, then maybe those officers will go home to their spouses and children without bringing the toxicity of the prison with them. They're seeking to learn about themselves so they can end the cycle of violence they themselves are caught in. Just remarkable. So we've been focusing in our teaching on these slogans, these lojong slogans. And there's a whole history of them there, associate with Atisha. They date back to the 11th century. They probably go earlier. And the idea is you take a slogan and just repeat it to yourself over and over and over and over. And that it'll just start coming up when you need it in your life. There are 59 of them, so quite a few. Sometimes the men will change them. And so I have a couple of examples. And one of them, which relates very well to today, he had a slogan and his slogan is I am peace. So he would say this to himself over and over. And one time he came in kind of excited into the class we were doing. This was at PNM. And he was excited to tell us something and he was telling us this insight he had. And he said there was a situation in the chow line. Someone was acting up, disrespecting him, and that's a big deal. Your reputation's a big deal. And he was escalating with it, trying to get the better of the situation. And then it popped in his head, I am peace. And he paused and he kind of tried to send that peace out. And he said the other person kind of looked at him a little bewildered and just walked away. So I was so happy to hear that. I was like, oh, it works. The slogans are good. This is good. And there are other slogans that are used. And so yesterday we were going through the book and we're kind of going through an order. And the slogan, one of the slogans we were teaching is one that is that I use in my own practice. And that's the practice of giving and receiving. The practice of tonglin. And I was kind of not sure how to bring it up to teach it. Because I didn't want it to be just like, here's this method. They're very into methods sometimes. They're like kind of like how to do things. So I wanted them to have this experience. And I was thinking about Zenkir, thinking about Uji. Like how do we, like we're asking them to like take on the suffering of others in the midst of their own place. Their situation, like if you picture this, it's all concrete. It's all gates and fences and doors. Constant sounds. It's never quiet. People yelling. And if sometimes we, if you ask them, what would you do if you get out? Because they like to fantasize about that. The most common answer I've heard is I would walk barefoot on grass. And they're completely separated. And this practice is about connecting. So it's kind of like, how do I, how do I bridge this? And then a few days ago in the chaplaincy training, Mary read a poem by Titchh Nakhon and here it is. The sun has entered me. The sun has entered me together with the cloud and the river. I myself have entered the river. I have entered the sun with the cloud and the river. There has not been a moment when we do not interpenetrate. But before the sun entered me, the sun was in me, also the cloud and the river. Before I entered the river, I was already in it. There has not been a moment when you have not intervened. Therefore, you know that as long as you continue to breathe, I continue in you. And that last line structure, as long as you continue to breathe, I continue in you. And as Kodo said, I'm an epidemiologist and I was kind of taking it a little literally and thinking about what is that? How does that work? What does that mean? And so my science brain got a little triggered. And so with apologies to Roshi, I'm going to teach Tonglin using math. Take a breath. You just inhaled approximately 1.2 times 10 to the 22 molecules. For me, that number means something. Like 10 to the 22, a lot. Like there are probably 10 to the 22 stars in the universe. Just inhaled that. But I really, that doesn't, you know, and I think about, like we read these sutras with all these crazy things, like 32,000 lion thrones in Vimalokarty's tiny room and things like this. This is like even more astounding. 10 to the 22 molecules. So they're each about 0.3 nanometers, the nitrogen, oxygen, carbon dioxide. And that's 0.00000014 inches. So I asked this yesterday to the guys, like, what do you think if you stacked them end on end? 10 to the 22. How high of a tower do you think you'd get? And they said, oh, you still wouldn't even see it. They're so small, or maybe like an inch. The answer is it would stretch almost to Neptune. And that's in every breath these molecules were exchanging. So what we see in the air isn't just emptiness, it's filled. You just can't see them, right? And as I breathe, my air goes out and I breathe your air and we're exchanging this air. And then you're headed in the trees and the whales and the blue-green algae and everything in the earth. We're just exchanging the air. We're connecting. And that's for me, I was thinking, well, the air is still there for them. Still connecting them. So I have these 10 to the 22 molecules going out, 4.4 billion kilometers if you were wondering. In each breath. Let's go a little deeper. Let's take the Buddha. Buddha lived for 80 years. So if you do the math, he breathed about 630 million times. Which is about 7.56 times 10 to the 30 molecules, which is just massive number. And let's assume some of those molecules are breathed more than once. So take a breath. You probably just breathed in about 100 million molecules that the Buddha breathed that were inside his body, or their body, or inside your body. Like when you do the statistics plus under regression, if you want to know, it's close to 100%. Or as close as statistics will give us 200%. Every time we breathe, those molecules that were inside his body, their body, are right here. But the Buddha's not special to mathematics, just a person. So if every time we breathe, those molecules are here. The molecules of every person, about 100 billion people who've ever lived, they're also here in this breath. So just breathe in. They're all right here. So now, hold on to your raucous ears, let's go deeper. When the Buddha said, when he awakened, he said, how wonderful, how wonderful I and all beings together are awake. I put out 10 to the 22 molecules. Take three breaths, go up to three. About a 99% chance that at least one of those molecules, you just breathe it in. So one molecule when the Buddha declared the enlightenment of all beings, right here, in your body, every breath. And again, that's not a special moment for mathematics. Anything someone said might be right here on those molecules that came out. Maybe the first time your parents told each other, they loved each other. Right here, the breath I took when I held my first children, had two at once. Awkward. Of this right here. Maybe your grandmother's last breath, those molecules. They're right here, all right here. Prize of joy, prize of anguish. That time as a teenager, when you slam the door and said, go away to your parents. It's here too. Breathe it all in. This is the lojang practice of receiving. And now we'll move to the practice of giving. So I'll take a collective breath and each of our 10 to the 22 molecules we go out. And as we send them out, we can charge them. Light, love, peace, with goodness. We can send them. Let's send them to the children in Gaza. Just one breath. And those molecules circulate out of here. The air and hair probably turns once, 10 times an hour or so. They'll fly out and they'll go into the jet stream. In about 40 days or so, they might be over in Gaza. After a little more time, they'll spread out across the atmosphere. And send it to the soldiers who find themselves for whatever reason, whatever causes them condition, fighting. Whatever circumstances brought them there. So the people holding together communities and families. All these molecules will flow with the winds and move and be carried. We can give a breath to our future selves. Molecular that'll be there. Maybe when we get some bad news, it'll be there. Maybe a molecule of our own last breath will be there. This is the lojang practice of giving. So now in the remainder of the time, I'd like to do the practice. I like to, it's often sending and receiving, it's called, but I like to switch it to receiving and sending. And so now we'll go over how this is done. And then if it's ever too intense, you can just drop the practice and go to your breath. And one thing to note is the way, at least we teach things here at Upaya. This would be a practice and I use this practice to bring in what's called bodhichitta, which is the intention to be awakened to benefit all beings. And when we sit in our practice, we want to, the first thing we do is for a time, cultivate that intention and use it to fuel our practice, create determination. And so we'll try that here. And so this is the more traditional way of teaching it. As you breathe in, you can imagine you're breathing in suffering. Sometimes you could just picture something you're struggling with yourself, someone you know, someone close to you. And then as you work on the practice, you can expand it further and further, further further and out as it feels right. And if you wish, you can imagine that suffering as kind of a black smoke, kind of traditional and you breathe it, breathe that black smoke, the suffering into your body. And as it comes in, you imagine, you visualize it melting away. Someone will say, picture ice around your heart and it melts away. Melting away whatever's holding you back, your defenses, your hesitations, whatever that is. The suffering melted away. And then change it and change the suffering into peace. You can exhale peace on this Veterans Day, on this Armistice Day. And visualize it as white light going out as an energy into the world. I'd like to think it of as 10 of the 22 tiny little messengers. But however you want to, let's try that for a few minutes. Just breathing in, letting it melt away and sending light and love. And now let the Tonglen practice drop away. Drop away and just sit. Nothing to do. Just be with whatever's coming up. And then may any merit we've gathered by this practice go to making Veterans Day obsolete. If there are no wars, there are no Veterans. Thank you for your practice.