omnist.world

Deutsch

Theravada · Compare this tradition with another

Devon Hase: The Path Slopes Gently: Anupubbasikkhā and the Gradual Training

Devon Hase · Dharma Seed - Dharma Talks (Insight-/Vipassana-Tradition, Aggregator) · 2026-10-30 · Barre · Source

Patience · main message Humility · carrying Community · carrying

Das buddhistische graduelle Training (Anupubbasikkhā) ist ein schrittweiser, fürsorglicher Prozess, der durch Vertrauen in die Bedingungen und die Gemeinschaft zur Weisheit und Befreiung führt, ohne das Ziel zu verfehlen.

Halte deine Augen auf den Weg zur Spitze gerichtet. Setze deine Bestrebung. Aber vergiss nicht, direkt vor dir hinzusehen. Der letzte Schritt hängt vom ersten ab.

Der Text beleuchtet das Konzept des graduellen Trainings (Anupubbasikkhā) im Buddhismus, das als systematischer und beschreibender Rahmen für die spirituelle Praxis dient. Devon Hase nutzt die Metapher des Gehens und der Wegmarkierung im Wald, um die Fürsorge und den schrittweisen Charakter der Übung zu veranschaulichen. Es wird betont, dass die Praxis sowohl aus konkreten Anweisungen (Dana, Sila, Bhavana, Panya) als auch aus dem Vertrauen in den bedingten Charakter des Weges besteht. Die Zuhörer werden ermutigt, ihre persönliche Bestrebung zu erkennen und diese dem Prozess anzuvertrauen, ohne das Ziel zu verfehlen. Ein Zitat von René Daumal unterstreicht die Notwendigkeit, den Fokus auf den nächsten Schritt zu richten, während man das höchste Ziel im Blick behält. Der Text verbindet persönliche Erfahrungen aus Retreats mit der historischen Praxis wandernder Mönche und modernen Pilgerfahrten. Er schließt mit einer Einladung an die Gemeinde, ihre Absichten zu reflektieren und in der Gemeinschaft der Schüler (Sikkha) zu ruhen.

Worldview

what this means
What, according to this text, is the root of the evil?
Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality
Where does the evil reside?
in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual
What helps against it?
prayer, worship, meditation, repeated practice; solidarity, mutual help, belonging
What is human being according to this text?
entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free
Where is history heading?
it is getting better, development towards the good
What does the text base its claim on?
on the founder or prophet of the tradition; on tradition, the fathers, an established practice
To whom does the text's call for devotion apply?
to one's own fellow believers
Where is the text's criticism directed?
the text does not criticise

Related texts from other traditions

by similarity of the analysis, one text per tradition

What the text calls for

Measured

Basic stance
1 from -2 to 2
Insistence
2 of 3
Reach
3 of 5
Concreteness
2 of 3
Boundary
0 of 3
Time
past 2, present 3, future 2

Analysed with qwen/qwen3.8-27b, version v3. The same standards apply to every tradition, see Values.

Show the full text
So fair warning, I'm going to turn the lights on. I know some of us really love the dark. I just don't want you to be too startled when all this light comes on. So one of my favorite parts of retreat is just sitting up here and waiting while you all come in so quietly and gently. And especially on a night like tonight when it's so windy outside, there is a special kind of coziness I find. And we're inside and we're all gathered here together and it's a little more still and gentle in here. My first three month retreat, I was sitting right there and it was in 2012. And I remember discovering the trail system out in the woods back here. I hope many of you have found all those maps. And I remember just marveling at the effort it must have took to make those maps. I mean how many of them? There's like 30 something and they're all like numbered and you know there's the red trail, the connectors and then the orange loop and the yellow loop and the effort that somebody went to to paint the trees with the trail blazers and then mark those places, all the different points and the intersections so kindly so that we can find our way in the woods. And my mind always orients to like what's the best one? Is it the yellow or the orange loop? And I could never decide. Definitely had to explore all of them. But really feeling so supported by whoever made those maps, you know, person, a group of people maybe. And now it's been really so delightful to have a relationship with those trails and those trees. And over the years watch how they've been repainted, the blazes have been repainted and some of the trees have fallen. And some of the trees with the signs have fallen and then watch how people have reposted the signs and cleared the trails of those fallen trees. And the way that the rivers in the springtime have changed the map of the woods. I find so much care in the woods back there. You know, it's the people who have helped us walk through them, but it's the trees that have been mentioned. You know, the trees holding us with Metta and this sense that so many have gone to the woods for support, for solace, for accompaniment. And even on the days where I didn't feel heavy with grief or doubt, I would still go and just feel the sense of being able to offer whatever was in my heart and be held by something bigger. So much healing, I think, is done in those woods. And so we have a kind of metaphor coming to being. You heard Bante speak beautifully about the joys of the Noble Eightfold Path and then knock away describing the Four Noble Truths also as a kind of pathway to freedom, a path of practice, of liberation. And so I want to continue that metaphor this evening by talking about the gradual path, Anupubhavasika, which is a frame you're going to get all the maps. It's another frame for the way that this practice unfolds. And maybe as I speak about it, you can have that sense of whoever made the trail maps out back similar. It's similar, right? Someone tracked these phases and they walked these trails and these paths so that we can also now, right, follow in the footsteps that we see in the woods. Just step by step. It's gradual. And this is what we're doing here. So Anupubhavasika is systematic, a progressive training, and it really describes like so many of these others, the ways that the path unfolds. It's both prescriptive, you do this and then you do this and then you do this. And it's a descriptive. If you just sit and practice, follow the instructions, this is how it will unfold. So you can listen as both the practice instructions and also a kind of what to look out for those blazes on the trees. And there's lots of ways, a complex way to talk about the gradual training, the gradual path, and a simplified way. Tonight I'm just going to simplify it down into four steps, which is dana, generosity, sila, ethics, bhavana, cultivation, and panya, wisdom. And I love that it's gradual, right? It's just step by step. The metaphor of walking is woven throughout the story of the Buddha Dharma. Our teacher, the Buddha, our teacher, he made his path by walking it, right? If you go to Bodhgaya at the Mahabodhi stupa, the sacred place where he awakened, the representation of the Buddha, where he was said to sit under this huge bodhi tree, is two footprints. And originally for generations before there were statues of the Buddha, it was only just these two footprints that symbolized and represented our teacher. He went about barefoot, they would go on alms round, they would go on pilgrimage, they would walk from place to place. This is the way the practice was done. And then Thai forest trishin, I know we have people actually here who have done the toodong practices, that kind of wandering practice, where you basically, it's like toodong literally means shaking off or renunciation. So these renunciates, they go on wandering retreat for months and years, and they have a bowl, spare robes, a razor, sewing equipment, matches, a water kettle, and a tent that's called a glutt, which is basically protection from the mosquitoes. That's it. And all they do is walk through tiger infested jungle. That's their practice. So this movement, this walking, this steady step by step. A friend of ours heard us talking about the beauty of pilgrimage, because I love to do walking retreat, walking pilgrimage. And one time I was sharing about this, and he told me about this journalist named Paul Salopec. Anybody know about Paul Salopec? He's a long-form journalist who started walking 13 years ago, and started, he wanted to trace the great migration routes, the original human migration routes out of Africa. So he started in Ethiopia, and he's been walking for 13 years, through Ethiopia, through the Middle East, through Asia, crossed the ocean on a boat, and landed in Alaska, and is still walking. And his whole route is going to take him all the way down the West Coast through to Patagonia, about halfway done. And today I discovered actually National Geographic has a live map of his trail. So it's very cool. You can see where he's been, and then you can see this little dot, right up in Alaska, where he is walking now, you know, for maybe 13 more years. And it's beautiful to read his journalism. He does these long stories about his walks and the people he's encountered, and he uses words like sacramental time. Like it's a uniquely human pace. This was part of his intention to slow down to this uniquely human pace, and he says that his feet, they feel like the stylus on a record player. Or like maybe some of you have had an insect land, and you can feel that soft pad of a fly or an ant or a ladybug on your skin. So there's a whole heartedness in this sacramental time, in this sacred pace of walking. Walking a path, of moving along a path. Just step by step. And in the Pali, the word for path and fruition, maga pala, I always thought it was beautiful words. Maga for path, pala for fruit. This is the whole frame. This is the story of us. And there is a path and a fruition, and the Buddha says this again and again. We just start walking on this maga, and we will experience the pala, the fruit. And it's a paradox, because we have a sense of moving from one place to another, and yet, you keep hearing us say, be present. The body is always in the present moment. Don't futurize. Don't get stuck in the past. The only thing ever is now. So this is paradox. There is movement. There is an A or an B. And it's only ever happening now. And it's also gone as soon as you've arrived. So Joseph really loves to use this quote, Rene Domal in Mount Analog. He's naming it well. He says, these are our practice instructions. Keep your eyes fixed on the way to the top. Set your aspiration. But don't forget to look right in front of you. The last step depends on the first. Don't think you've arrived just because you see the summit. Watch your footing. Be sure of the next step. But don't let that distract you from the highest goal. The first step depends on the last. So it's only ever happening right now, and yet it's okay to have this highest goal for freedom and liberation. That's why we're here. We're told not to cling to it, and we'll talk about that. But it's okay to let your heart rest on this sacred path that has been walked by so many before us, and hopefully so many to come. So Anu Puba Sikha, the word root of Anu means following along, and Puba means what came before. And then Sikha is related to this word Sika, which means disciple, or one who is in training. So it's a beautiful sense of lineage, I think, actually. This connotes the sense of, like, we're aware of what has come before us, and we're also aware of who maybe is to follow. And we're, as a humble disciple, we're walking along in lineage, in a kind of accompaniment, actually. So this bow to those who have gone before, the devotion and the trust in their practice, knowing we can believe the Buddha when he says, I teach this because you too can do this. That's us. We're the Sikhas, the ones in training. And also this sense that what comes before has a following, right? There's a step-by-step process, a cause and effect experience that we have. And we start to get very precise as we practice. The causes and conditions that lead to well-being. That's the wisdom that grows. So we set our aspiration, but there's a kind of immediate release. Like, then we can give that over to the triple gem, because our job isn't to, like, make sure we push and strive and get to our goal. Our job is just to learn a lot about the conditions that then let that path unfold naturally, as it will. And it's all baked into this word, anupubhavasi ka. Like, trusting the conditionality of this path, trusting that what comes before will have a wholesome result, will lead onward. That's the nature of this. So a couple days ago with the part two yogis, we did a little bit of reflecting on our intentions together. But I think it's really important to do this regularly. And so you might just drop in briefly here now and ask what is your heart longing for? What is this aspiration that you hold? So beautiful I can feel the shift in the room. And it's a deep aspiration. It's an honorable one, whatever that may feel like or sound like for you, each maybe our unique one. It's worthy because we're doing something hard. It's not so easy to do this practice. And so you can trust, you can rest your heart in these aspirations that we have. They matter. And there's so much goodness. However lofty or humble our aspirations may be, I just want to calm down a little bit. Or I want to save all sentient beings. They're all worthy. And they're so important to know, to be intimate with this aspiration, this longing we have in our hearts to be free. To grow in wisdom and compassion. There's so much worthiness here. And if it is uplifting to remember the goodness of your heart, the altruism, why you're here, even the mystery of why you're here, you might not even know yet. But to remember that frequently, start the day maybe. Start every session just tapping into this goodness. Like, yeah, I'm here because I care. I care about the world. And I care about waking up. It's important. And it's such a blessing to just feel the room, right? And to feel it in a room of quiet beings who are resting with their hearts intent. That can also be a refuge, right? It's our individual aspiration, but it's the felt sense of we're doing it together. So generosity is the foundation. Generosity is the foundation of this path. I like to think about the practice of generosity in retreat as breath by breath. Breath by breath. We're receiving and releasing. Generosity has both movements. It's a receiving and a releasing. Every moment we're receiving and releasing. We're offering, right? We're making ourselves an offering. We're making of our practice an offering. And there's this, again, this paradox that we have this. I've spoken with many of you already. I know that there's this spiritual urgency that we have. There's this dhamma-chanda, this wholesome desire to practice. And sometimes even that, it's like so painful to sit with the depth of our urgency. And what I've found just sitting here for months on end in these halls, burning with my urgency, trying to wake up, is that the good medicine, good activity to do with all that urgency is to offer it. When you bow and just be like, give it to the Buddha, you can give your heart to the Buddha. You can make a prayer, but not to have to hold all that in you, to let the whole path hold it. That's a generosity. That's an offering. Even this painting that's on the stairs, you know, you guys have read it million times now as you go up. It says, try to let go of expectations and then everything can open up to you. That's a generosity. Some of you have told me today, I don't have a lot of expectations for this retreat. Generous heart. That's dhana. Every time we let go, every time we learn to just find a little space in a tight mind, a contracted body, that's dhana. Every time we sense into the movement of our neighbor, then we might adjust how we're walking through the hall or we kind of, somebody today, like, moved the spoon over for the tomato so I could reach it across the table. That's a generosity. You know, can you feel that sense of a heart that knows how to let go and actually loves it, you know, feels the beauty of that generosity every moment. And it's beautiful because it's not you. It's just the nature of this path that understands letting go is the way. So I'm talking a lot about clinging to dhamma because this is what happens in retreat, at least for me, my clinging is really around, like, I just want to practice so much. It's so hard. So I was practicing a long retreat at the Forest Refuge. I was there for six months. I had a good long time. But most of my walking practice was spent fantasizing about the next, even longer retreat that I was going to do. And I had it all planned out, my fundraising goal and how I was going to do it somewhere in Oregon and be on my own in this cabin and watching these whole, like, fantasy worlds take birth as I was walking in the meadow in the Forest Refuge. And feeling the duke of it, actually. Like, I could see reasonably that I was in ideal conditions. Like, it was spring and there were flowers and it was perfect weather and I was at the Forest Refuge. And my mind was all planning this other bigger, better, like, princess cabin retreat. And just in that moment, it's so, actually also, I'll just say, so many insights come through walking. Like, the biggest ones I've had have not, I mean, cushion is good too, we like stillness, but walking meditation is like all these insights come when we're moving. And so all of a sudden I kind of saw how the world and that meadow was presenting itself to me moment by moment. And that was the only thing that was real. Like, all the fantasy and the story and the plans, they were not real. And it was like, oh, I'm planning my future liberation, but actually the only time I ever get free is now. And the way I get free now is just by letting go of all of that seductive fantasy and be here. Which is also a pretty good moment. So you can trust that each moment is worthy of your liberation. Each moment is worthy of that kind of two-handed whole-hearted attention because this is the time you get free. And it's a humble freedom. Often we're looking for big fireworks. You know, we assume, oh, the Buddha had these big fireworks and the earth quaked and the gods sang and choirs, you know, the whole symphony started for him. Like, good, so happy for you. I'm just gonna sit here and like release my exhale. Sometimes I have them sitting and like waiting for the fanfare. But it's so quiet. It's so, so quiet. Letting go is like, what's not here, you know? Your liberation can be humble that way. James Baldwin said it this way. There's never a time in the future in which we will work out our salvation. The challenge is in the moment. The time is always now. So as we learn to let go, to release, receive and release, we have this sense of goodness. And we've talked already a lot about these precepts. Sila, Sila such a beautiful word. And of course then the English translation is so clunky. It's like morality, ethical conduct. So Sila, we could just say Sila because it's uplifting, right? This foundation of pointing to our own goodness. Also having to do with refuge, right? We take our refuge and our precepts. We find safety. It's so psychologically wise that the Buddha said take refuge first. Align with your goodness first. Because it's a hard path and we're gonna come up against all these edges and feel scared and there might be apparent danger. But we keep finding our wholeness in refuge, our wholeness in our goodness. In being aligned with harmlessness and truthfulness. And this heart that feels clear and in integrity. So my friend and colleague, Young Oh, talks about how the whole practice of refuge and precepts is like loving ourselves back into wholeness. Right? Remembering our wholeness. We're all splintered everywhere and yet we come home to safety. This community of care. The sense of like I can find protection in my own goodness. And it helps us trust ourselves. Right? Because Sila is so trustworthy and we start to see a word trustworthy in that. Sharon Salzburg talks about this turning point. It's a great turning point in our spiritual lives. When we go from intellectual appreciation of a path to the heartfelt confidence that says yes, it is possible to awaken. I can too. Have you had that? It's possible. I can too. A tremendous joy accompanies this confidence. When we place our hearts upon the practice, the teachings come alive. That turning point which transforms an abstract concept of a spiritual path into our own personal path is the path of faith. Right? That trust. And Sila is what helps us develop that trust. And I think by finding our own goodness and aligning with it and feeling that bliss of blamelessness, everything then becomes sacred. We have this sense of integrity and there's an alignment that makes everything meaningful. The way we're moving our body, the way we're using our speech internally, our thoughts. There's a kind of... they get blessed. They're like sacrosanct. There's a meaningfulness. For me it's just a sacred. Then everything's imbued with this sense of blessing. And you can feel that from the Buddha all the way down. He blessed us this way. He's like, I found goodness and it's in you. And here's how you do it. I mean so generous and compassionate that teaching. I believe in you. That's our teacher. That's who we're following here. Path of goodness. And then of course we start to see everything sacred. The historical Buddha is our teacher. Also nature is our teacher. And we have an inner teacher. When we're in Sila there's this sense of an inner guide, a compass. So more and more there's that sense of turning this path into our own. And in retreat we have all of this support for sense restraint, for simplicity. For understanding the conditions that lead to this goodness. It's like, I don't need a lot of the stuff that I think I need in retreat. Some of you who have been here for a while you feel that. Just the simplicity of the routine and the simplicity of your tea or whatever you're doing. Your life is what I do. It's simple. The privacy and the gift of less eye contact, less concepts and words. But sometimes for some of us a little bit complex in here. It's an acquired taste. The simplicity and the sense restraint. So I remember, I mean I still have this in retreat. But a lot of this sense of like, should I go have tea? Should I go walk? What's the best thing? What's renunciation? Would it be letting go of this or that? Or should I go early to meals or late? Or how is it letting go? But really it's like this balance of understanding you're already in a p