Skip to content
omnism.si

Queer community · Compare this tradition with another

When Forgiveness Becomes a Weapon

Queer Theology Podcast · Queer Theology Podcast · 2026-11-08 · Source

Justice · main message Mercy · carrying Truthfulness · carrying

Vergabe wird zu einer Waffe, wenn sie als Pflicht verstanden wird, die das Recht auf Wiedergutmachung und die Benennung systemischer Ungerechtigkeit aushebelt.

Denke einfach an die Wege, auf denen „Gott vergibt mir“ als Waffe eingesetzt wurde, um zu sagen, dass queere Menschen, Frauen, schwarze Menschen, Menschen, denen ich unfreundlich begegnet bin oder die ich missbraucht habe oder was auch immer, keine Beschwerden haben dürfen

Die Hosts des Queer-Theology-Podcasts, Brian G. Murphy und Shannon T. Elkerns, reflektieren über die Ambivalenz der Vergebung in christlichen und queeren Kontexten. Sie kritisieren die Nutzung von Vergebung als Waffe, um Leid zu relativieren oder Wiedergutmachung zu umgehen, insbesondere im Kontext von Inhaftierten und systemischer Ungerechtigkeit. Der Text unterscheidet zwischen individueller Vergebung und systemischer Unvergebung sowie zwischen göttlicher und zwischenmenschlicher Vergebung. Am Beispiel des jüdischen Yom Kippur wird argumentiert, dass Vergebung zwischen Menschen nicht durch Gott allein abgewickelt werden kann. Die Sprecher fordern eine differenzierte Betrachtung, die Wiedergutmachung und Gerechtigkeit neben der Vergebung stellt. Sie warnen davor, Vergebung als Pflicht zu instrumentalisieren, die das Leiden der Betroffenen ignoriert. Der Text plädiert für eine ethische Haltung, die sowohl Barmherzigkeit als auch die Benennung von Unrecht berücksichtigt.

Worldview

what this means
What, according to this text, is the root of the evil?
Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community
Where does the evil reside?
in the economy, politics, or social structures
What helps against it?
practical action towards the neighbour, good works; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding
What is human being according to this text?
self-determined, the author of one's own actions
Where is history heading?
it is getting better, development towards the good (inferred)
What does the text base its claim on?
on personal experience, testimony, encounter; on argument, logic, science
To whom does the text's call for devotion apply?
to every human being, regardless of faith
Where is the text's criticism directed?
explicitly at both

Related texts from other traditions

by similarity of the analysis, one text per tradition

What the text calls for

Measured

Basic stance
1 from -2 to 2
Insistence
2 of 3
Reach
4 of 5
Concreteness
2 of 3
Boundary
1 of 3
Time
past 1, present 3, future 1

Analysed with qwen/qwen3.8-27b, version v3. The same standards apply to every tradition, see Values.

Show the full text
Welcome to the Queer Theology podcast. I'm Brian G. Murphy and I'm Father Shannon T. Elkerns. We're the co-founders of QueerTheology.com and your hosts. From Genesis to Revelation, the Bible declares good news to LGBTQ plus people and we want to show you how. Tune in each week on Sunday for conversations about Christianity, queerness and transness and how they can enrich one another. We're glad you're here. Before we dive into this episode, we just wanted to remind you that our new book, Reading the Bible Through Queer Eyes, good news for LGBTQ plus people from Genesis to Revelation, is available for pre-order now. You can buy it anywhere books are sold. We're super excited to share these quintessential stories from our decades of work, queering the Bible and making this work accessible to people. So the book is available for pre-order now. It comes out in December and we hope you'll grab a copy. Hello and welcome back to the Queer Theology podcast. Today, we are going to tackle a subject that, I don't know, if you're like me, maybe gives you a little bit of anxiety or fear or nervousness. We're going to talk about forgiveness. I'm the one who suggested this topic, so I'm going to share a little bit about why I've been thinking about this. I grew up in a church tradition that very much talked a lot about forgiveness, mostly that we were all in terrible, terrible need of it because we were hideous, horrible, wretched people, but that Jesus would forgive us. And that also it was important for us to forgive one another, which was generally offered with a sense of obligation. You were obligated to forgive other people. And so I think I, like many people who grew up in that tradition kind of pushed back on that and repelled from that as I got older of like, no, you don't get to tell me that I'm obligated to forgive people. I don't have to forgive anyone. Mm hmm. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But lately I've been thinking about forgiveness again, particularly because I'm doing more work with folks who are incarcerated and I notice particularly online, right? Someone will post a picture of someone who's in prison or and maybe share about something that they're they're struggling with while they're incarcerated, some injustice that's happening to them. Or even maybe they'll post a picture of someone who's, you know, getting out of prison or someone who has just been convicted of a crime. And the comments are just filled with people being like, well, what did they do? Or they deserve to burn or, you know, it doesn't matter if they're facing injustice in prison, like they shouldn't have done the crime, right? And just like really hideous things. And it's easy to say that is trolling people on the internet. The internet brings out the worst of people. I get that. But I'm also noticing that when I talk to progressive friends, right, they'll have we'll have conversations about like, well, if you've been convicted of a certain kind of crime, maybe like you definitely should not be allowed to attend a church or to be in community where there are other people. And and so I've been thinking a lot about like who who gets to then forgive what happens if people aren't forgiven? And more more particularly, you know, we talk a lot about forgiveness as an individual thing. But what happens particularly when unforgiveness becomes systemic? And like, how does that play out in people's in real people's lives? Right? This is not a hypothetical. And so that is a kind of very high overview of of some of the things that we're going to explore today and why that's been on my mind. And so I'm curious, Brian, like for you, a what has been your journey with both the idea of forgiveness and also what is what I've said, like bring up in you? Yeah, well, definitely. Well, what immediately what it brings up for me is the like my history with my husband's family. And I don't know, like, maybe it's because it's this time of year. It's like November, December and holidays tend to be fraught with families. But I like I think about the ways in which they harmed me and us and the ways in which like they sort of like expected slash demanded forgiveness. In some ways, like didn't even like acknowledge that there's anything needing forgiveness. And like in the areas where they might acknowledge that they'd like done wrong, like expecting slash demanding forgiveness immediately in a certain way, performed in a certain way, on a certain timeline with certain expectations attached to it. And so like that is like the most like my like my most like visceral in my body immediate. I was like, that's where my mind went when I like zoom out a little bit. I think like you, I grew up sort of certainly hearing like God forgives and that like God can forgive anyone. And if you, but it was very much like if you say that if you say the prayer, right, and when you're an ask for forgiveness, you like cleanses your sins. And so you could be like an awful person and a murderer or whatever. But if you accepted Jesus before you're before you died and like ask God for forgiveness, then like all would be forgiven. And that would just sort of like the end of it, which in some ways is like quite radical, but also in some ways was just sort of like, well, what about all of the good people? All along, which I guess is like the subversive point. Like there is, I actually do think that there is something there about like no one being beyond forgiveness that still sticks with me. But then like how that played out, I think like interpersonally was like, if someone says they're sorry, you just have to accept it. Face value, say you forgive them and then move on. And I think for as much as we like talked about like the word repentance, it was like repenting from sins. Generally, there was not necessarily any sense of like repentance in terms of like doing things differently or like making amends, being paired with or even in conversation with forgiveness until like I grew up and I encountered social justice and like liberal Christianity and Judaism and all those types of things where I was like, oh, there was like some repair work that has to be done and actually to contrast forgiveness and like the Christian worldview in Judaism. So because you don't know like Yom Kippur is like a annual holiday. It's like the day of atonement and it's sort of like where the forgiveness that forgiving happens sort of. But in Judaism, like you can ask God for forgiveness for the like quote like sins that you've committed against God. But if you've harmed another person, the forgiveness has to come from them. God's like, that's between you and this person. Like I can't like I can't just like wipe your slate clean. And so like traditionally the month leading up to to Russia, not the last month of the Jewish year, Russia, Shana's in a year and then the 10 days before until we're not Yom Kippur. It's traditionally a time of like introspection and making amends and asking for forgiveness where it's where it's like warranted. And so I remember like the first time that I learned that I was like, wait, wait, like Judaism is like actually like God doesn't want to be involved. Not doesn't want to be involved in that. But it's like you have you can't just sort of like bypass human forgiveness by being a God forgave me for it. So that's like that's good enough because I was like, just like think of the ways in which like God forgives me has been like weaponized to say like queer people, women, black people, like people who I was mean to or abusive towards or whatever, like aren't allowed to have any grievances because like it's just done and dusted and supposed to be in the past now. Even though it's like, well, I never got to weigh in on that. So those are kind of like my scatters on forgiveness. And I think that's really interesting because that in some ways dovetails with with what I am experiencing, especially with folks who are caught up in the. The criminal justice system or injustice system, whatever, mass incarceration, right? Because there is a sense in which. It for many of them, it it's not. They don't ever get to have a conversation with. The people that they've harmed, right? It's the state then that steps in and either, quote unquote, forgives or doesn't forgive, gives a penalty or doesn't give a penalty. Right. And we know that like whether or not you get forgiven or not and what kind of penalty you get or not like depends on your gender and your race and your socioeconomic status and what neighborhood you lived in and your family, right? Like all of these different things. And it does feel. Then. As communities or society or Rando's on the Internet, step into that conversation. They also feel that they are owed some kind of debt or payment or suffering of the people that have done harm, whether or not that harm was done to them or not. Right. Like, you know, we see like I, you know, in those angry commenters, like get all of the people that did X, Y, Z off the streets, lock them up whenever. Right. And it's like, OK, but like, you don't actually they did not hurt you. They aren't even in your neighborhood. And yet you feel justified. And that also feels to me like a very. Evangelical. It's like the flip side of, mm hmm. Yeah. Like the flip side of God forgives everyone is like God is also going to send a bajillion people to hell. And they're lining up of good people and bad people in your. Yeah. And we're kind of gleeful about it, right? Like there is a sense in in evangelicalism. It feels like especially now, I don't know, maybe it's always been there of like. Yeah, we want everyone to get saved. But man, those people who didn't sure are going to get what's coming to them. And like we're going to happily watch. Right. It's not us. Yeah. I think about the hate messages I get again on social media. But I'm sure that some of these people would gleefully say it to my face of like we can't wait to like watch you from heaven burning in hell. And it's like, OK, me thinks that like God still has some work to do in your heart. But OK. But it does it feels to me like there's something really interesting. And and I don't like I honestly part of the this is like me processing out loud of like. I don't think that we have a good way to talk about forgiveness as. Communities. Mm hmm. It right. It feels it feels a lot easier for me to grapple with. What is forgiveness look like in your relationship with Peter's parents? And like what what is owed and what isn't owed and to whom? Like that all feels very clear in a lot of ways, whether or not like anyone gets on board with that conversation is really to have it. Like that's a different conversation. But like we can look at it and be like, oh, and we can probably point pretty clearly to like this is what repair would look like to whereas when it's something else like that gets really complicated. And I remember this might have been in our conversation with Rabbi Rutenberg, where she was saying like. You can't offer forgiveness for someone else. And so like if someone, for instance, has been murdered, like there is no one like that family. The family can't offer forgiveness for the person that's been murdered. Right. They can offer forgiveness around the harm that they've experienced because of that act of violence, but like on behalf of the person who has died. But so then like, what do we do? Like as a community, how do we heal? And I think the bigger question for me is how do we welcome people back into society, community, et cetera? Because like what we know from prison systems is that 96 percent of people who are in prison will come home. So like the idea that we're talking about a vast amount of people who would be locked away forever. Like that is not the majority of people who are incarcerated. And so what does it mean that 96 percent of people will come home and come back into our neighborhoods, our stores, our YMCA's, our gym, our churches, our synagogues? Like what do we do with that? Right. And. Some of those people are in jail for like what I consider like we're like bullshitty things, right? Like possession of marijuana, like loitering, sleeping in public, like public urination. And then like either like that becomes a jailable offense or like that sort of like the inciting incident. And then they get like slammed with resisting arrest or like trumped up charges, et cetera, et cetera. Right. And so we can sort of be like, oh, well, like, I don't know. If like if someone ends up in jail because they were like smoking pot on the street corner or even like doing cocaine on the street corner or even like doing heroin, like in an alleyway, like who like who is who is the victim? Who has been harmed by that person doing heroin on the street corner or in their and the alley or in their bedroom? Right. And like maybe like their actions like caused harm. But like Manas is like sometimes it's like not that they let them let them to jail. Right. And so like that's like one type of person. Returning to community. But then there are also people who it's like it was for like theft or assault or rape or like fraud or any number of crimes that like really clearly did like harm a person or like a group of people specifically. And so then like because there's some of those words like for it was like anyone in jail for marijuana. It's like, I don't know. Just like let them out. Who cares? It's like, I don't I don't actually need anything from them. Right. But I know that's like not everyone who's in jail. And so then so to your point, like what does that look like on a when there are individual like individual people there? And I don't have an answer right now, but it does feel like as someone who wants to imagine a different way of being in the world and wants to imagine a world without prisons. Like I it feels important to grapple with that. But also it feels like like me sitting here in my in my home office grappling with it by myself is like maybe a good starting point, especially if it like affects the way that I talk about strange on the internet or to people about people in real life. But like I'm not going to fix the system like the prison system or institutional injustice or forgiveness or even like how we handle people who have like done harm in churches or religious community and what is like forgiveness look like on a not government level, but like still some sort of institutional level. I don't know, but it definitely feels like it's a relational question that like needs to be done alongside of other people, whether that is like inmates themselves like prison people in within the prison system or whether it is with like victims or probably both that it's like weak. It's not enough to just like sit on the sidelines. So I say that and then I'm like, I got information for you about about what was it? It wasn't even it wasn't even being a prison pen pal. It was like transcribing. Transcribing. Yeah. Art art. Transcribing art and stories and poems like written by people incarcerated. And I was like, I'm going to do this. And I like bookmarked it in my email box. I think I even like started the process of like filling out the form. But I like, you know, life happened. And so I'm also like aware of like so that so the question that I asked myself is like, is that sort of a feeling of myself? Like do I need to like double down and like get back on that and and and and do that or like to what at what point is it sort of like, where does my I could only do so much? And like, these are going to be my causes that I focus on. And this is a cause outside of myself. And so like maybe the prison system is like a cause outside of my that's like that's someone that I'm going to like support other people doing like they're going to that's going to be their focus and my focus is going to be elsewhere. I don't know. But also forgiveness just feels like so it's not just about prisons and quote unquote offenders. It's also about like, like, even like my parents, like my parents, they've like, we've I think we've reconciled really well. But like, the reconciliation that has happened in my in my own life with my immediate family, the reconciliation that maybe hasn't happened with my in-laws, but that are like, we sort of have a truce, the like harm that your family has done to you, like to interpret like everyone can think of, I'm sure people who have hurt them the times in which they've hurt other people all the times that they have forgiven have been forgiven, haven't forgiven. And so like that, I don't I can't solve institutional questions. But like they feel both like connected and also sometimes I'm like, well, I don't know, I'm not going to solve the prison today. Yeah. And I think you're right. And also I think what what I'm so struck by, right, is that if we can't start to change how we think about the thing or the people, like we can't actually change the system. Right. And so like, if I sit down with my progressive friends and they're like, well, I don't care. I don't care about the prison system and I don't care about the people in it, right? Like then they're not actually going to do anything ever to change that system, even if they could, right? Even including like voting differently or thinking differently about their voting. And I think that one of the things that I'm that has been so challenging and impactful for me, even in like reading more about mass incarceration is realizing how much of my own psyche is like trapped in notions of punishment and like, like, I don't know. I get cut off in traffic and like I want that person to get pulled over. I'm not necessarily proud of that thought. And also if people don't learn how to use their fucking turn signals, I'm going to lose my mind. But like, but like there is right, there is a real sense of I find in myself when I get angry or when I feel that I've been wronged, even if that wronging is like something so inconsequential as getting cut off that like I feel in myself a move towards punishment. Now, the thing is like, I don't have the power to actually punish this. But I mean, I guess I could like have a road rage and road rage incident and like pull out a baseball bat. Right. That's not. I don't have. Yeah. That's my. Right. But like, but it has been so, I think, uncomfortable to notice that in myself and to be like, oh, I too, and part of these systems, not even because I'm like voting a certain way or like giving money, right. But because I too, have been trained in a system that says, obey first, ask questions later. If you just follow the rules, you'll be safe. Right. Like all of these different things and all of that like gets bound up in then into like who ends up in prison. Right. And so I think you're right. This all is communal and and also it starts with this internal reckoning that I think we all have to do about how we feel about these things. And like and I think it does it coming back to that kind of forgiveness thing of like asking the question of like. What can I forgive? Like what in my own life can I forgive? Where are the places that I feel like I can't forgive and why? And like, what does that look like? Mm hmm. And and I'm and I'm not even talking like theoretically of like, well, if this happened to me, do I think I'd be able to forgive the other person? Like, I don't necessarily think that that is a hopeful thought exercise. But it but it is interesting to think of like, oh, who are the people in my life that I don't feel like I can forgive and and why is that? And what is that doing to me? Yeah, if anything. Yeah. One of the things I think about is like that I really had to unlearn was this idea of like good people and bad people. And I think like it like to your point, I think you can like really trace it back to conservative Christianity. And in particular, like like reform, Christian, like Calvinism, like wh