Skip to content
omnism.si

Theravada · Compare this tradition with another

David Loy: Loving the World as Our Body: The Nondual Path in a Dangerous Time

David Loy · Dharma Seed - Dharma Talks (Insight-/Vipassana-Tradition, Aggregator) · 2026-11-18 · Barre · Source

Community · main message Knowledge · carrying

Die ökologische Krise ist die logische Konsequenz der durch Achsenzeit-Religionen etablierten kollektiven Täuschung, die den Menschen als von der Biosphäre getrennt und auf eine transzendente Erlösung hin orientiert sieht.

Im Kern der ökologischen Krise liegt das kollektive Gefühl der Trennung der Menschheit von der Erde, was ziemlich interessant ist, wenn man die buddhistische Kritik am Selbst in Erinnerung ruft, die im Wesentlichen auch eine Kritik an der Trennung ist

David Loy identifiziert die ökologische Krise als Folge einer kollektiven Täuschung, die den Menschen als von der Natur getrennt wahrnimmt. Er argumentiert, dass diese Trennung historisch durch die Achsenzeit-Religionen (wie Buddhismus und Christentum) vertieft wurde, die einen kosmologischen Dualismus zwischen dieser Welt und einer transzendenten Realität schufen. Diese Religionen fokussierten sich auf individuelle Erlösung und Abwertung der materiellen Welt, was zu einer Entfremdung von der Biosphäre führte. Loy stellt fest, dass die archaischen Gesellschaften zuvor eine engere Verbindung zur kosmischen Ordnung hatten, die durch den Zusammenbruch der Bronzezeit und den Aufstieg der Erlösungsreligionen verdrängt wurde. Der Text kritisiert die traditionelle religiöse Ausrichtung, die das Leiden dieser Welt als bloße Bühne für ein jenseitiges Ziel betrachtet. Er schlägt vor, dass ein Verständnis dieser historischen Entwicklung notwendig ist, um die ökologische Krise wirklich anzugehen. Loy plädiert implizit für eine nicht-duale Perspektive, die die Einheit von Mensch und Welt anerkennt, um die Selbstzerstörung der Zivilisation zu stoppen.

Worldview

what this means
What, according to this text, is the root of the evil?
Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality; Hostility, hatred, the breakdown of community
Where does the evil reside?
in the epoch itself, in the condition of the age
What helps against it?
insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding
What is human being according to this text?
above all a part of a community or of creation
Where is history heading?
it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end
What does the text base its claim on?
on argument, logic, science
To whom does the text's call for devotion apply?
also to animals, plants, and all of creation
Where is the text's criticism directed?
at one's own community and at oneself

Related texts from other traditions

by similarity of the analysis, one text per tradition

What the text calls for

Measured

Basic stance
-1 from -2 to 2
Insistence
2 of 3
Reach
5 of 5
Concreteness
2 of 3
Boundary
0 of 3
Time
past 3, present 2, future 1

Analysed with qwen/qwen3.8-27b, version v3. The same standards apply to every tradition, see Values.

Show the full text
First of all, thank you to Cambridge Insight Meditation Center for this invitation. It's my pleasure to be back with you again. It seems to me that the ecological crisis is the greatest crisis that humanity has ever faced with the added irony that we're doing it to ourselves, aren't we? It's not as though we can blame it on an asteroid or something like that. And of course, we can be understood in different ways, given that some people benefit from this resistance more than others. I mean, there are certain wealthy, powerful people in corporations that are still making too much money selling us fossil fuels and so forth. We could go into that. But instead, what I'd like to do is sort of look at the ecological crisis from the other direction, which is to say, why? Where did it come from? How did it develop? If it's the case that we want to really address it, it might be of some benefit to understanding how we got here in the first place, which I think is maybe especially relevant for us because I think religion, our main religions, including both Buddhism and Christianity, have played a significant role here. At the heart of the ecological crisis is our humanity's collective sense of separation from the earth, which is kind of interesting when you remember the Buddhist critique of self, which is in effect also a critique of separation, the Anato teaching of early Buddhism that says, in effect that our usual sense of self is a psychological and social construct. The feeling of separation is a delusion. And today, what we're facing, the situation we find ourselves in, is the collective delusion that we as a species are separate from. And therefore, we can distinguish our own well-being from the well-being of the rest of the biosphere, all the other plant and animal species. And you could say the ecological crisis is sort of the logical consequence of that collective delusion. But again, where did this delusion come from? How has it developed? I think it's no coincidence that this time of eco-crisis is also a time of spiritual crisis. Raising this question, what is the role? What should the role of religion be today in our increasingly secular, materialistic, and now globalized civilization? A civilization to say it again that in some way seems to be self-destructing. The two religions that most of us here are most familiar with, Christianity and Buddhism, they're different in many ways, but they share something very important. They are both what are sometimes called axial age religions, religions that developed in a certain period in the first millennium, I mean, especially when you include Christianity and its Jewish roots, really developing in the first millennium BCE. But let me contextualize that more generally, more historically. For most of human history, we lived in small groups, really bands of mobile hunting gatherers who of necessity were very much in tune with their ecological environment. They had to be. You know, you've got to know where the, you know, the roots and the berries and the other fruit are, you need to know where the animals that you want to hunt are going to be. So there was naturally a kind of attunement there, which changed radically with agriculture, which many archaeologists would say is the most extraordinary, the most important transformation in human history, in which case, you know, we settled down and it also created, interestingly, the separation of inside and outside, right? You've got the village and you've got the fields, the tilled fields. And soon after agriculture, we got domesticated animals. So now you've got inside and outside, the wilderness is outside and you've got to protect, you know, your land, your area, your fields from other animals and other humans who might want to encroach on them. So again, this beginning of inside and outside. But in the earliest archaic civilizations, sometimes called bronze age civilizations, the sense of separation really wasn't that much, right? I'm thinking about the civilizations that you found kind of all over Eurasia, the Mediterranean, Greece, Egypt, but also India and China. One of the really distinctive things about them is that they didn't make a significant distinction between religious authority and political powers, the whole secular sacred distinction that we tend to take for granted in principle, that didn't exist between church and state. The rulers were theocratic, right? Themselves, they were God or Godlike or they became gods when they died. And they had a crucial role in sort of maintaining the relationship between human society and kind of the cosmic order. For everyone else too, social roles and religious obligations like sacrifices and other rituals, they were important because they maintained the kind of sacralized social order, the cosmic order, you see? In other words, in those societies, we as humans still had an important role to play in the cosmic order in keeping things working. That's why the rituals and the sacrifices were so important, very different from the way we think about religion today. But notice the implication. We in the process of having this role to play, we believed, we knew, we took it for granted that we were part of something greater than ourselves. We were responsible to it. We had a role to play within it. These Bronze Age civilizations flourished for a long time from about 3000 BC until, well, things started breaking down around 1200 BC. And when the collapse happened, you know, it happened all over Mediterranean, Middle East, India, China, often very violent, catastrophic, although the causes are still debated. But in the aftermath of this, maybe in response to the kind of chaos and suffering of this breakdown, you got a new kind of cultural or, let's say, spiritual development, the Axial Age religions. Which, as I said before, it includes Buddhism and Christianity, along with the other Abrahamic. The Axial Age is a term coined by the German philosopher Carl Yaspers, axioled in the sense of axis, like a pivotal period, when, as he said, quote, the spiritual foundations of humanity were laid simultaneously and independently. It's quite interesting. Seems like they were independent. But these new kind of a new way of understanding the world, a new way of understanding religion that developed China, India, Persia, Judea, and Greece. And you got these new spiritual revolutionaries like the Buddha, like Zoroaster in Persia, Lao Tzu and Confucius in China, the Hebrew prophets, including later Jesus and Muhammad. It's interesting. None of them was like an official temple or priest. They were all kind of originally marginal for the Christian. They were all figures, you know, responding to this kind of widespread social and moral failure collapse. And what happened was they ended up creating new visions, new religious conceptions that contrasted this world, this world of suffering, this unsatisfactory world of, as Buddhism would say, greed, ill will delusion, contrasts this world with a higher reality. Some idealized transcendental transcendent realm. Right. You think for Christianity and Islam, that's heaven for Buddhism, right? Think about the contrast between samsara and nibbana. Right. And along with this contrast, this cosmological dualism, as I call it, there was a shift to more individual relationship. It's like we all have the same Buddha nature. We're all children of God. There's like a moral requirement, moral expectation that we will behave in certain kinds of ways that would involve some kind of self transformation. So the focus isn't on just sort of preserving the civilization or the society. Now the focus is more on the individual, in fact, creating what we know as the individual. So instead of trying to preserve the larger social cosmic order, now the goal is salvation. But salvation from what? The short answer is salvation from this world. Salvation became a possibility for all of us, not just for, you know, kings who become gods, but for all of us according to how we live. One of the reasons this is sometimes hard to see if we kind of take this for granted that this is what a religion does. But as I've just tried to say, you know, these salvation religions were something new. And it seems to me from our perspective today, we can say that this kind of salvation, this kind of cosmological dualism, it had two serious flaws which limited their relevance to our difficult situation. They still limit their relevance. Cosmological dualism, which I've also already mentioned, and individual salvation. Here's the big problem. Belief in another and better reality that we can access after we die. This is the cosmodualism. In effect, that tends to devalue this world right here and right now. Right. I mean, it's very clear in Christianity, this world is merely a kind of backdrop to the human drama of sin and salvation. And for Buddhism, too, right, this is some sorrow, the place of suffering because of our craving and ignorance. In that case, why worry too much? Why be too concerned about what's happening here when our eternal bliss is going to be somewhere else? Right. If this is simply a staging ground for that other place that we're hoping to get to. And of course, this implied another dualism that has become especially problematic for us today between humanity and the rest of the biosphere. So our traditional religions, these axial salvation religions, they didn't focus on taking care of this earth. The focus was on a salvation that would escape from the trials and tribulations of the suffering of this world. I mentioned also individual salvation as an important part of this new way of thinking, which ultimately means, of course, that my well-being is separate from yours. Right. Sure, I hope you're going to make it to heaven or attain Nirvana of Nirvana, but in either case, my own spiritual destiny won't be affected. Now, for Buddhism, this changed somewhat when, you know, the Mahayana comes in with the idea of the Bodhisattva ideal, the Bodhisattva path. Okay. Historically, it seems to me that this new kind of spirituality promoted these salvation realities, salvation from this world, promoted by the actual age religions in an important sense. It failed. There were certain revolutionary personal, more egalitarian implications. But in fact, what happened is that pretty soon despotic rulers and empires sort of took over and sort of tamed the revolutionary potential of these new religions. Like for, say, for Christianity with Constantine, the Roman Empire, Constantine in the fourth century, with him, you could say Christianity transformed into Christendom, right? Later, European kings ruled by divine right. And likewise, some of their Asian equivalents who must have had very good karma from their past lifetime, some of the emperors in China, for example, they claimed to be Bodhisattvas, Buddhist Bodhisattvas or even Buddhas themselves. And of course, we know how Christian teachings have been used to rationalize the forceful conversion of pagans, persecution of Jews, heretics, subordination of women, crusades, establishment of brutal empires and so forth. To the point where now what is now known as Christian nationalism, it seems to me it's really an oxymoron in the sense that it has very little to do with the teachings of Jesus. But that's another direction I won't go into for the moment. But here's the important thing I think the good news is that the best the heart of the Axiolage teachings have survived in an important sense that I will just get to in a moment. And they've served an important role in helping to develop democracy, human rights. But still, I think it has become difficult, it's increasingly difficult to take the kind of sacred mythologies and theologies that they offer literally. Especially when they talk about belief that the goal of the spiritual path is a transcendent salvation that supersedes and escapes whatever happens here. Today, I think it's becoming clear that to revive their revolutionary potential, we need to question and recuperate the insights of their founders in a different way. A way that I think updates the way the spiritual path has been understood. And this is something that the ecological crisis certainly calls us to do. Although most people still identify I think with one of the Axiol religions, the biggest in the world still are Christianity and Islam. Insofar as they emphasize some kind of postmortem salvation in another reality, it seems to me at their heart they are incapable of responding adequately to the problems we face here, this reality. I recently came across an interesting quotation from the Emerald podcast, quote, we don't want to go to other planets because our planet is dying. Our planet is dying because we perpetually want to go somewhere else. I think today it's increasingly obvious we need a spirituality that focuses on realizing the true nature of this world, which as Zen asserts also happens to be our own true nature. I mean, we too were manifestations of this earth, not exiled spirits that should be preoccupied with qualifying for eternal bliss somewhere else. If we can learn to cope with our fear of death, which I think is a major motivation for this focus on postmortem salvation, we don't want to die. Perhaps we don't need that kind of otherworldly reward. Maybe we can find a kind of salvation, if you want to call it that, right here and now. Maybe the challenge is not to transcend this world, but to transcend our usual way of experiencing it. Because it turns out, as we know, those of us who are practitioners, it turns out that this world is in fact quite different from what we have often thought it to be. Joseph Campbell liked to say that all religions are true one way or another when understood metaphorically. The problems arise when those metaphors are taken literally. And I wonder if that applies to the cosmological dualism. Perhaps what we call the spiritual of the sacred, it's not something higher apart from this world that occasionally interjects itself into this world or influences this world. But maybe the spiritual of the sacred is the ever present ground or the source of this world. Maybe the impermanent phenomena we experience every day, including ourselves, are the manifold ways that the sacred is taking form and expressing itself here and now. And when we look for that in our spiritual traditions, we find it. In most of them, it's usually called mysticism, a broad term that refers to a variety of spiritual experiences, of course. But I think the one, the most insightful ones involve what you might call unmediated awareness of an ultimate reality right here and right now, in which case the usual duality, sense of duality between a me, a self that's inside and an objective external world outside, that sense of separation dissolves when we are able to, as Dogen puts it, let go of ourselves. I think it's no coincidence that the principle mystical traditions, and here I'm including the main Abrahamic ones, Judaism, Christianity, Islam, as well as the main Asian non-dualist ones, which include Buddhism, Vedanta, Dalism. All of these traditions agree that the fundamental obstacle to God realization or enlightenment, whatever you want to call it, is the ego self, the subjective pole of the self-object duality. As Buddhism would say, the delusion of a self that's separate from the world. Most of the great mystics have emphasized this when they talk about how to experience God or Brahman or the Tao. And even in Shamanic cultures, if we want to go back older, prior to the Axial Age religions, it's interesting how the candidates to become a Shaman, they almost always have to endure a difficult trial that involves a kind of regression. Sometimes you have plant medicines to help with this, a kind of regression to what's called an undifferentiated condition. Very much a dissolution of self, ego, death, and it's only after that that there can be a kind of a rebirth here and now, quotation here from a scholar of Shamanism, there's always a point where the potential Shaman remains for a time on the threshold, experiencing the primal void, a state of unbeing, and its greatest mysteries. Only when he surrendered himself utterly can he be reborn. Does that sound a little bit familiar to us? But I mean, there are so many other examples in the Jewish Kabbalah, for example, when we empty our self of selfhood, we reach true reality. And one of the names for that in the Jewish tradition is divine nothingness. In his letter to the Philippians, Paul exhorts us to follow the example of Jesus, who humbled himself and made himself nothing. This is the canosis. Likewise, the great German mystic Meister Eckhart encouraged the same self emptying. Quote, if you could not yourself, right, if you could make yourself nothing just for an instant, you would possess all. Sufism too, quote, what did Rumi say? If you could get rid of yourself just once, the secret of secrets would open to you. The face of the unknown hidden beyond the universe would appear on the mirror of your perception. Asian non-dualist traditions, like Vedanta, Buddhism, Taoism, we tend to describe the absolute and more impersonal terms, but it's the same. The spiritual path involves pretty much the same transformation, letting go of self, ego death, rebirth into a transfigured world, which is not somewhere else but here and now. As Vedanta says, we perceive the everyday world the way we do due to our ignorance, but when true knowledge dawns, we're freed from the delusion of self and wake up to our true nature. The most important teaching in the Upanishads, Atman is Brahman. Atman, the self, the true soul, the self is not other than Brahman, the ground of the universe. We've always been one with Brahman. Again, right here, right now. For Taoism, the Tao usually translated the way, it's the inexhaustible womb of all life, an empty vessel that yet may be drawn from without ever needing to be filled. In other words, again, becoming no thing is how we return to the source from which everything originates, including us. And so Taoism too talks about mind-fasting, Wang Xin, which is how we can forget our usual dualistic sense of self. And as I mentioned before the break, the Dao De Ching tells us that the world may be entrusted to those who know and love the world as their self. But what about Buddhism? For sure. It seems to me actually the most single most important person in the whole of the Buddhist tradition, for me anyway, after the Buddha himself is the Indian philosopher Nagarjuna, lived about 150 AD. And his really important texts, the Mula Mediama Kakaarika, was kind of foundational for the whole of the Mahayana. Now, if you've heard of him, if you haven't read much about him, you've probably heard the famous saying that samsara is nirvana, right? Actually, he never said that, at least I've never seen it. What he did say very clearly is that the Koti, the place that is samsara, is not other than the Koti of nirvana. In other words, nirvana, very clear for him. Nirvana is not some other reality, nothing transcendent to this world. But it's the true nature of this reality right here and now. This great quotation from his great chapter on nirvana, there is no specifiable difference whatsoever between nirvana and this everyday world. And then he goes and distinguishes them. He says, that which taken as causal or dependent is the process of being born and passing on is taken non causally and beyond all dependence declared to be nirvana. Granted, that's rather obscure, especially when I read it so quickly. So let me try to unpack what I think he's saying. We usually experience the world as a collection of things that interact, right? Including us. We learn to see it this way as we grow up. We're socialized into perceiving it, relating to it in the way that everyone else does. And of course,