Skip to content
omnism.si

Zen · Compare this tradition with another

Zen History: Informing our Practice and Lives Today

Upaya Zen Center Santa Fe - Dharma Podcast · Upaya Zen Center Santa Fe - Dharma Podcast · 2026-10-19 · Santa Fe · Source

This text has not been analysed yet.

Show the full text
Thank you for listening to UPIA's Dharma Podcast, an extraordinary series of talks from some of the finest teachers in the world. I'm Joan Halifax, founder of the UPIA's End Center, and we're happy to make these podcasts available to you. Please consider making a donation so we can offer these recordings freely. You'll find a donation button on our podcast page. And thank you so much. This is Dharma Podcast at DharmaPodcast.org. This is episode number 2674. It was recorded on October 14, 2026, and it is titled Zen History, informing our practice and lives today. The speaker for this episode is Kathy Fisher. Good afternoon, good evening. And where's the people online? Right up there. Welcome to all of you from all over, wherever you are. I could say it's wonderful to see you, but I can't see you. So it's wonderful to be with you in the way that we are. So I'm so happy to be here at Tassara, at UPIA. And I, you know, every time I come here, I'm just in awe of the work and the love and the commitment over all these years that each person who comes here brings and contributes to. We have wonderful residents. We have a history of wonderful residents, wonderful teachers, wonderful local sangha men. Local sangha members and visitors from all over. And of course, deep gratitude for Roshi Joan, who, whose vision allowed this place to come into being and to stay into being, which is a tall order these days. So her work, her vision, her commitment just goes on and on. And we are so deeply grateful for her to her and for all the people who have committed their time, their love, their commitment to make UPIA be a practice place for all kinds of people, a refuge. So this is always an exciting moment because there's, you know, I wrote this, you know, I finished reading, writing it and I had it printed and that was a couple of hours ago. And I can't really say for sure that I remember what I wrote. So we'll find out. As Kodo said, I am going to talk a little bit about Zen history, first of all. How, first of all, how Soto Zen tradition differentiated from Rinzai. And that happened gradually, primarily in Japan. So Japanese ancestor Hakuin created undoubtedly in collaboration with others the codified curriculum of Kouan practice. In which students, a student is given successive Kouans to work with, meets with the teacher repeatedly to demonstrate her understanding until each Kouan is mastered according to the requirements of the curriculum. Hakuin was a beloved and highly acclaimed Japanese Rinzai Zen teacher. There's a famous story about him in which a young woman accused him of fathering her child. The young woman and her family go to Hakuin's temple to hand him the baby and confront him with this. His only response is, oh, is that so? He took in and he cared for the baby. The young woman felt badly about this. And at some time later, she confessed to her father, to her family, what she had done. That is, falsely accused Hakuin of fathering her child. Horrified by the news, the family came to the temple to apologize to Hakuin and take back the baby. Hakuin's response was, oh, is that so? So Hakuin's reputation was badly damaged and was not ever repaired by this event. Yet he never defended himself nor blamed anyone else. Defending himself would mean accusing someone else and he wasn't willing to do that. Hakuin lived in Japan from 1686 to 1769, which is when the 13 American colonies were gaining identities, fighting in the French and Indian wars, seeing increased friction with Great Britain over taxation and territorial expansion west into Native American land. This is many centuries later than the collected koans from the Tang dynasty, almost a thousand years later. During those nearly thousand years, koans were collected, commentaries were written, and they were used as teaching tools or teaching inspiration. A few years ago at Opaya, here at Opaya during fall practice period, excuse me, so a few years ago at Opaya during fall practice period, we studied Hongzhe. He was a brilliant and beautiful Chinese ancestor who we would consider soto. He taught silent illumination. Yet his best buddy and contemporary was Da Hui, who we would consider a Rinzai teacher, kind of a kick butt Rinzai teacher. These best friends sparred with each other while maintaining mutual respect and warm friendship. In fact, Hongzhe bequeathed his temple to Da Hui. When he died, he also asked him to do his memorial service for him. So these were close friends and their teaching style was different, but they learned from each other. They nurtured each other as they came forward with their own style of teaching. So this tells us that the divide between soto and Rinzai was not really firm and solidified. It became so later in Japan. Hongzhe lived three Dharma generations before Dogen came to China. So Hongzhe's years were 1091 to 1157, so 12th century mostly. And Dogen came to China in 1223, so he came well after Hongzhe died by the next century. And Dogen met his teacher, Rujing, who was the Dharma great grandson of Hongzhe. So Hongzhe to Rujing to Dogen was, there was a continuity there. And it was another, from that time, from Rujing and Dogen, it was another 500 years before Hakuin, who was the one who codified the koans in the Rinzai tradition. And there are three main koan collections that we know and use. The Blue Cliff record or the Heki-Gon Roku, the Gateless Gate or the Muman-Khan, and the Book of Serenity or the Book of Equanimity, the Shoyu Roku. Many of the same koans appear in two out of three of these koan collections. But there's a little different emphasis in them. A pattern we can notice in many koans are that the questions are general and the answer specific. I'd like to talk about this observation for a few minutes. If we ask ourselves where we find general and where we find specific, we might see that generalizations are conjured by the mind. They are intellectual. Experiences that are momentary to eyes, ears, nose, tongue and body are specific. They cannot be other than specific. We don't perceive sounds as generalizations. They are loud or soft, high or low pitch. They have a timbre, etc. We don't sense pain as a generalization. Pain is specific, characterized by sharp or dull, specifically located, etc. Our mind is a sense, you know, in the heart sutra. Eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body and mind, they're all lined up together. And according to Buddhist teaching, it's one of the senses. In the Upaya translation of the heart sutra, we chant, realm of eyes to realm of mind consciousness. So realm of eyes, realm of ears and so on. To realm of mind consciousness. So the realm of eyes is light waves. That's what we see with our eyes, light. The realm of ears is sound waves. That's what we hear. The realm of mind is synthesis. Mind synthesizes. It collaborates with the other senses to create a perceived, functional pattern that we can act on. When I'm working at my desk and I hear the sound of rain on the roof, I look out and I see the day has grown darker. I'm likely to locate my umbrella and place it by my shoes for when I go outside. The information came from my eyes and ears. The action plan came from mind. As we know, mind is a busy bee. It's likely to synthesize this and that to no purpose or to negative purpose, like repetitive self-doubt. Swinging to this and that, even when there is a known destructive outcome, mind is often on high functioning mode, even when there is nothing needed. Meditation instructions often includes or is even defined by quieting the mind. I once read a book called The Moral Animal by Robert Wright. He came out in the 90s in which he talked about camouflage in animals. As you probably know, camouflage is a defense strategy usually for tricking a predator. For example, becoming small, still and invisible. You know, I'm a retired school teacher and I know that some kids use this strategy so as not to be noticed in a classroom, to avoid speaking up. This behavior can pursue a person into adulthood. We notice in Dharma discussions that some people always hold back and some always come forward. Another camouflage strategy is to look like a different animal that has an effective defense. For example, the monarch butterfly is toxic when eaten by birds and other animals. It probably won't kill them, but it gives them a nasty stomach ache, such that they will leave monarchs alone after that until their family and their neighbors do the same. Several other butterfly species have evolved similar coloring to the monarch, tricking animals into thinking that they are monarchs and therefore avoid being eaten by birds, at least somewhat. So basically the butterfly is lying. Well, according to Wright's speculation, this is a model for human behavior that we all know well. That is lying. And as it turns out, we aren't such good liars unless we believe the lie we tell ourselves. So self-deception, according to this book, is an evolutionary survival strategy. I'm not presenting this as a fact. I think it's pretty speculative. But even so, it's a useful example of what we're up against in our effort to purify the mind, namely evolutionary inheritance. Mind capable of all kinds of wonders, as well as destructive and self-destructive thoughts, then is a major focus in Buddhist practice. There are lots of books about training the mind because our chimeric, fast-moving mind easily goes off the rails. Zen practice, beautifully articulated in the teachings of Zhao Zhou, asks us to learn to give mind a break, to allow it to rest. What sound, sight, body feeling without or with very little mental filter? I mentioned, let's see a couple pages ago, that mind tends to generalize and the senses are always specific. I want to tell you a little story about me, something that happened to me about six months ago. I've told some of you already. And what I learned from it, and it's what I learned from it that I want to actually tell you, but I have to tell you the story. So I like to run a little bit, even though I'm kind of old, I still like to run a little bit. I just love it. I was running on a trail near my house, near our house in Muir Beach, and I tripped over a rock and fell on my face, full, full, you know, full, you know, plant. So yeah, my son, I talked to my son, he said, my son, he said, Aaron said, Mom, that's called a face plant. So anyway, I broke my nose and the next day my eyes were black and purple and magenta. That's when I changed to these purple glasses by the way. And I, you know, Norman was one day sitting at Green Gulch and he came home and took me to the ER and I was just fine, but you know, it shakes a person up to fall like that and turn purple and pink. But after, you know, after I sort of was recovering and feeling my legs were fine, there was no, it was just my face that took the blow. So I thought, I really love to run. And I cannot fall. I am too old to fall. People cannot fall. So what am I going to do? So I thought, what I'm going to do is I'm going to put my full attention on the bottom of my feet when I run. And I'm going to see how, if that helps. So after that, I mean, I have been doing that practice before. But now I was really motivated because it was like for my safety. So I, I ran a little bit. I ran a little bit, I started a little bit and then increased it and walked and just practiced putting my full attention on the bottom of my feet. Each step in contact with the earth, one after the other, after the other. And at first I had to kind of keep reminding myself, come on, you want to do this, right? So, and then after a while, it just became such a pleasure. It's a beautiful practice and I recommend it. It's first of all, I don't know about you, but when I'm outside walking, sometimes I'm flying off into Never Never Land thinking about this and that. And it, you know, puts me where I am. I feel in contact with the whole earth, my body in contact with the earth, and I feel safe. So it's a practice that I recommend. And I also recommend inventing practices for yourselves like this that fit your life, that fit your need. That, you know, we have mindfulness practice and things like that, but you can get very specific to your body, your need. And especially if it kind of take hold the way my, putting my attention on my feet did, that it's just a wonderful meditation. I just wanted to tell you that. So, our practice. Sitting in the body, just breathing, without too much thinking. For me, one of the most beautiful expressions of this practice is in a koan, not of Jaudro. I'll get to that. But of Yunmun. Yunmun lived at the end of the Tang Dynasty into what's called the Five Dynasties Ten Kingdoms Period. It was about a 50 year period between the Tang and the Song Dynasties in the 10th century. Right? Yes, 1900s. So, here's the koan. And also I wanted to say that so Yunmun's years overlap with Jaudros and they probably knew each other. Jaudro is a very famous Zen teacher in his time. So this is the koan. A monk asks Yunmun, how is it when the tree withers and the leaves fall? How is it when the tree withers and the leaves fall? You know, I said the other day somewhere about the question. Our tendency in our culture, I don't even know if it's only our culture, but in our culture we want the answer. Hop over the question and get straight to the answer. Right? But in Zen, the question has the energy. The question is energetic. If you look at the koan questions, they're very, very good. They're very good, very skillful. And the koan survived as much on the questions as on the answers. It calls forth the human moment of wondering, a good question, of longing. The question is what reveals the answer. How is it that the tree withers and the leaves fall? And this question also has the sense of an experienced practitioner and also an aging person. How is it when the tree withers and the leaves fall? Yunmun says, body exposed in the golden wind. Body exposed in the golden wind. Wind means breath. The golden wind means breath. Whole body consumed and bathed in breath. There's no implication or analysis here. It's not symbolic. It's just breathing as it is. Exquisite. Experience we have in common for our whole lives. It's a beautiful, lyrical, and accessible statement of Zen practice. Body exposed in the golden wind. That's my time. I want to share two stories of women in Zen. I told you in my first talk that I'd read that Jha-Jha met with a number of women. We don't have much record of this. And as I mentioned in my previous talk, I wonder what happened to the records. But I have two stories with women that I'd like to share with you. The first is from James Green's book, The Recorded Sings of Zen Master, Zhou Shu, is Japanese. Zhou Zhou is Chinese. Same guy. So Anun asked, setting aside the explanations given until now, please instruct me. Not a great question. So this nun seems to be in a depth. She's asking him for a direct response. She's asking him to meet her. Zhou Zhou shouted, burn an iron bottle to ashes. Burn an iron bottle to ashes, you may ask. The nun then went out and poured the water out of an iron bottle and brought it to the master saying, please answer. And Zhou Zhou laughed. So the word emptiness in Sanskrit, I'm told, means an empty vessel like this iron vessel. The nun brought back to Zhou Zhou. And this empty vessel is open and ready to receive, which means that the word empty in Sanskrit, or the word shunyata in Sanskrit, does not have the same meaning as the word emptiness. So the word emptiness in Sanskrit does not have the same flavor as emptiness in English, which is sad. If I feel empty, you want to give me a hug, right? So this is a different, this really has a different sense. An empty container that's ready to receive. Huaiying told me, told us that empty in Chinese means something similar with open, with many possibilities. And this is what beginner's mind means. Suzuki Roshi's beginner's mind. Suzuki Roshi said, the mind of the beginner, in the mind of the beginner there are many possibilities in the mind of the expert. There are few. So the nun is saying, by offering this empty iron vessel, I am open, I am an empty vessel, not filled up with prior ideas and so on. She's presenting herself that way. And Zhou Zhou found it delightful and laughed. So in this koan, you know, when Zhou Zhou shouts, open iron bottle to ashes, you know, I think I already said that. Anyway, she presents herself emptied and Zhou Zhou laughed. She meets Zhou Zhou, where they both are. So that was a good meeting. Another story with a style of response is this kind of same, a very similar kind of response is of Lehmann Pong and his enlightened daughter Ling Zhou. We studied them a few years ago for a practice period. Once when they were walking, carrying their wares, they crossed a bridge and Lehmann Pong fell down. He called out to Ling Zhou, help, help. And Ling Zhou ran up to him and fell down beside him. Pong said, what are you doing? And she said, I saw you fall to the ground, so I'm helping. And so both of these stories have the sense, especially the Ling Zhou, you know, how can we help another person? Can we help another person? We can stand by them. You know, both of these koans have the sense of, you know, one and one like that. Here's a story of Zhou Zhou from its case 30 in the Blu Cliff record. I'm good. A monk asked Zhou Zhou, teacher, I've heard that you have personally seen Nan Chuang. Is that true or not? Zhou Zhou said, Zheng Zhou produces big turnips. So the sense of this story is that everyone knows that Zhou Zhou has not only seen Nan Chuang but lived with him for 40 years. So he's saying, have you seen Nan Chuang? Well, it's not a yes or no question. It's a say something, say something, show me some Nan Chuang. So the monk is either trying to catch Zhou Zhou, that pontificating about his famous teacher or the monk himself is just wanting to hear Zhou Zhou lose himself in memories of Nan Chuang. We don't know. But Zhou Zhou is having none of it and comes back with a mundane, everyday fact that everybody knows, perhaps has immediate and perhaps has immediate importance. So, you know, that is about the turnips. These people lived at a time when there was tremendous political and therefore economic disruption. I'll talk about that maybe, I don't know, next week. But there's lots of stories that are not in the koans, but you can sort of find out little hints and sometimes the whole story. So anyway, I was thinking about this, you know, Zhou Zhou saying, tell us about Nan Chuang in Zhou Zhou saying, well, there's these turnips. It's kind of like, modern day version would be like, I heard that Mick Jagger once visited upaya. What did he say? Or did he sing? And the teacher answers, Red Lentils are on sale this week at Whole Foods. It's a bit of a slap, kind of a funny slap. And it makes the point to the monk, come on back to just this floor, walls and ceiling. Come on back. So these stories can be so helpful, not only in our zazen practice, also in our daily practice. Allow the senses to come forward and the mind to step back. Not completely, of course. Teach yourself to inhabit body more than mind. Teach yourself specifically. And when you can, because we know we, our mind is our superpower, we need and use our mind. But mind needs a break sometimes. So, for example, the pauses for mind to rest when we walk from place to place, when we eat, when we clean up, when we bathe our bodies, when we brush our teeth. Of course, everything we do includes mind. So I'm talking about the extra mental activity, the scheming, the anticipating, the imagining what the future will be, reviewing and reviewing again past events, past mistakes. Those mental activities have their place and time. But we tend to be on overdrive, engaged in mental activity out of habit or nervous anticipation. That we can learn to let go by placing