What Does Kindness Have to Do with Prayer? | 10@9 | 2026.10.29
This text has not been analysed yet.
Show the full text
Good morning. Today is Thursday, October 29, 2026. There are two themes that weave through the disparate narratives in this week's total portion by Eirah. One theme is the theme of kindness, hospitality, helping other people as a cardinal value of Judaism and as a primary way of serving God. And the second theme is prayer as a relationship with God, as a conversation with God that is ongoing. At the beginning of the parasha, God visits Abraham when he is in pain, an act of kindness, visiting those who are sick. Abraham and Sura show exemplary hospitality and kindness to strangers passing their way. And Abraham prays to Hashem to save the people of Sodom from destruction. And with that, Abraham establishes for us for all time, as we've discussed many times. Our rabbis understand that Abraham establishes the prayer of Shachris, the obligation to pray to God every morning. Abraham shows us the relationship with God that comes through daily prayer. Now these two themes, the theme of chesed and the theme of prayer, on the one hand, a theme that relates between one person and another, acts of chesed, kindness and hospitality. And the theme of spirituality, of praying to God. These two themes converge when Abraham prays for the recovery of Avimelach, using prayer for kindness. Torah tells us, towards the end of our parasha, Vayisa Misham Abraham Arca Hanegev, Vayeshe Ben-Kodeh Shebenshur Vayogar Begrar, Abraham moved to the southern part of Israel, and he settled in a place called Grar. Vayomer Avram El-Sara Ishto, and Avram said to the people there about his wife, Sara, Achosihi, she is my sister. Remember this happened earlier in last week's Torah portion, when Avram and Sara and Lot went to Egypt. Vayishlach Avimelach Melech Grar Vayikach Sara. Avimelach, the king of Grar, the place where Avram was living at that time, and he took Sara again, second time, like Paro had taken Sara in Matrayim in last week's Torah portion. But here the stories diverge. God appeared to Avimelach in a dream at night, Vayomelo and said to him, Heinchamesh al-h'isha'a shela kakta, I am going to cause you to die. You're going to get sick and die because of this woman that you took, Vayibu al-Asbal. She's married. She's a married woman. You took a married woman. Okay, Avimelach defends himself. He didn't know. Avram said it was his sister. Okay, but in any event, God says to Avimelach in this dream, Vayatah now, return this married woman to her husband. Her husband is also a prophet of Avram. You should ask Avram to pray for you that you should be healed. Vayom-einchameshiv, and if Avram is not willing to pray for you, that you should get better. Da, you should know, kimos tamus, because you will die. And then the Torah says, a few seconds later, Vayispalel Avram el-ho al-akim, Avram prayed for Avimelach, Vayirpa el-akim es-Avimelach, and God healed Avimelach. This is the origin, the first known instance of the widespread practice that when one person gets sick, another person prays for them. If I know someone is sick, God forbid, I would say to them, what is your Hebrew name and your mother's Hebrew name? I want to pray for you. This applies to anybody, but this also leads to the practice that some people, if someone, let's say, God forbid is sick, they will go to a tzotik, a righteous person, and say to them, please give a brahah, pray for this person to get better. When a person is in trouble, they go to another person. I'm in trouble, would you pray for me? The question is, how does this work? Why does this work? I can understand if I need something and I pray for myself, so I shall believe the listen or not listen. I mean, respond the way I want or not respond the way that I want. God always listens. I didn't mean that. God always listens, but the question is, maybe I shall more respond. But what good does it do if somebody else prays for me? So there are a number of approaches to this. One approach is presented as by the rub, Rabbi Yosef Salavachik, and it goes like this. The rub explains that our understanding of how the world works is that a person lives as long as in God's eyes, they have a mission to complete. And once their mission is completed, then the person is removed from this world. They have completed their purpose here in this world, and so they are taken. This is similar to a worker who is hired for a specific job. There are two kinds of workers. There's a worker who's hired, a full-time worker. You're just on call all the time. And then there's a worker who's hired to do a job. I hire a worker to install an air conditioning system in my home. So when they finish the job, they're finished. They go home, they do something else. They're finished. I have no more need for them. The rub explains what God is saying to Avimelech when God appears to him in the dream and says, listen, Avimelech, as far as I'm concerned, God says, you've completed your mission here in life. I have no more need for you to remain in life. And as far as I'm concerned, your life can come to an end. However, if you were to ask Avram to pray for you and Avram would feel deeply that he wants you to be healed and he wants you to live, Avram would feel that Avraham needs you, Avimelech, and therefore Avram would pray with feeling with his full heart that you should get better. So then Avraham needs you. Even if I don't need you, God says, but Avram needs you, so your mission is not complete. So I might listen to that prayer and to heal you because your mission is not complete, not vis-a-vi-mi, but vis-a-vi-avram. Otherwise it doesn't make sense because otherwise, if God wants Avimelech to pass away, then he would pass away, regardless of prayer. And if Avram, if God does not want Avimelech to pass away, God wants Avimelech to be healed, he should be healed even without anybody's prayer. But this is the point that Rav is explaining. The Rav is explaining that if Avraham feels that he wants Avimelech to live and prays with his whole heart, that means that Avimelech's mission is not completed in this world. If the person who's praying for the other is anguished by the sickness of the other, by the suffering of the other, if the person who's praying would feel a great loss, if that person were, God forbid, to pass away, and would therefore pray with their whole heart, I need this person. Hashem, their mission is not completed. I need this person to survive. I need this person to get better. That's a prayer that could be heard and accepted by God. There's a widespread practice. Someone will come to me, come to you, and say, there's someone who is sick. God forbid, would you pray for them? What's their name? Ruvaym Ben-Sara. I'm just making it up. There's a person, Ruvaym Ben-Sara, would you pray for them? People approach me sometimes and say that to me, or I know that there are groups of people that get together and they pray for a list of people. Ruvaym Ben-Sara, Ruvaym Ben-Rivka, Avram Ben-Sara, and a whole list of people. Now, I don't mean in any way to undermine that. I know that the people who are doing it are doing it with the best intentions. I'm sure that there's some way in God's, in terms of God's understanding, in terms of God, that that is important. I'm not undermining it. I'm just saying that I don't understand it. If I don't even know the person, how can I feel that I am anguished over what's going to happen? It's a stranger. I don't even know who it is. Okay. Again, I'm just saying I don't understand it. I don't want anyone to stop doing it. I'm sure it's holy and I'm sure it's valuable. I'm just saying I don't understand that. What I do understand is that the main component, if one person prays for another's well-being, is the amount of empathy they have. That I understand. If I feel that I am anguished over what you're going through, if something would happen to you, God forbid, it would harm me. I need you to be better. That is a prayer that we learn from the Ruv that can be successful. Now, what I said before about praying for someone that I don't know, I'm just being honest and confessing my own personal, I'm sure, is a shortcoming. But it's Satic, a person who is righteous. What does it mean to go to a Satic, a person who is righteous and ask them to pray for someone else? Part of what it means to be at Satic is to be able to have a level of empathy, even for someone I don't know. This person, Ruvane, the son of Sara, if I was at Satic, that would mean I'm able to somehow summon a level of empathy and a level of feeling and a level that I need this person so that that prayer is effective, that prayer is meaningful. That's what it means to be at Satic. Okay. But for me, the way I understand that it works according to the Ruv is if it is someone that I know and if it's someone that I feel for and it's someone that I can arouse myself with that full heart, then the Ruv explains that's what God was saying to Avimelech. If you can make sure that Avram feels this way about you, Avimelech, and he prays for you because he would feel your loss, anguished over your loss, that's a prayer that could be helpful and that's what happened and Avimelech was healed because of that prayer. So we see in our parasha this merging of the spiritual and the mundane where an active prayer which is service to God is an act of kindness to another person to cause their healing and this should inform the way we look at the entire total portion. In fact, all of life, but let's just focus on the total portion because maybe intuitively we might distinguish between those narratives in our total portion that are chesed, that are acts of kindness from one person to another of which there are several, and then there is another type of narrative which are acts between a person and God as prayer where we have several examples in our parasha and we may think of them as two distinct areas of life, but no. What we see from the narrative of Avimelech is that they merge and that is the theme of this total portion that kindness and hospitality and prayer, all three of them can be used to help another person and all three of them can be used as primary ways to connect to God. My friends, I wish you a great day and I look forward to seeing you soon in person.