Orthodoxy Live Mailbag Edition - November 8, 2026
This text has not been analysed yet.
Show the full text
This is Orthodoxy Live with Father Evan Armitage, a live interactive call-in program where your questions about the Orthodox faith are addressed. Father Evan is the priest at St. Spirit and Greek Orthodox Church in Loveland, Colorado. Call in your question at 1-855-AF-RADIUM that's 1-855-237-2346. Father now is Father Evan. Good evening and welcome to Orthodoxy Live, your live call-in show about the Orthodox faith, her teachings and traditions. I'm your host Father Evan and we're streaming with you this evening on Ancient Faith Radio. I'm glad you're with us. You've tuned in to a special mailbag episode. So if you're dialing into the number 1-855-AF-RADIUM, no one will be on the other end. We've prerecorded this session and taken questions that people have posed to us while we've been on air through putting questions into the chat box if they are streaming on YouTube or Facebook. Where people who've emailed us who are listening to the show, whether we're on air or off at OrthodoxyLiveAncientFaith.com. Of course, if you've got a question for us and you're listening tonight, you can't email me or wait for a live episode, which usually is just the next week on Sunday night. Mike, thanks for joining me again on the other side of the mic. I think our last mailbag episode, you took a little break, but you're back. Yeah. My IMDB page continues to swell with entries from OrthodoxyLive. I got to hand it off. Sometimes Simon and I have to tag team, but I'm happy to be on the co-host rotation and it's a pleasure to be here as always, Father. Yeah. Well, Simon did admirably in your absence, but I'm glad to have you back. As I mentioned in the intro, we take questions that we haven't had a chance to get to while we're on air. Oftentimes those are questions that have been either given to us in the chat room on one of the streaming services that we use or emails that have come to us. I've got a stable of questions and I don't know that we're going to get through any of the backlog in the next month or years. There's just so many. But I know we've got a few tonight that we'll take a look at and do our best to answer. So, again, you're listening to OrthodoxyLive here on Ancient Faith, we do a special mailbag episode pre-recorded and we're going to jump right in with our first question. All right. This first question comes from an anonymous questioner who writes, Father Evan, your blessings, Father. So I have a very good friend who is not a Christian. She knows I am and she knows how much it means to me. She recently told me that she has begun to read tarot cards and has bought a black pot so she can cast spells, quote-unquote. I know that the occult is a very real thing and how evil it all is. The Lord has told us these things are an abomination to him. My question is how do I handle this? Obviously, I will not join her in any of her practices. In addition to prayer for her, what can I do? I don't want to abandon her completely. I don't know if the Holy Spirit will pull her to him and if my continuing to invite her to liturgy, she may one day join me in church and hopefully she will stop the evil practices she's currently engaging in. Is there anything I can do or should do? I do pray before I see her and after I see her for the Lord to keep any evil at bay. Anonymous. Yeah. Well, we're pre-recording this episode before October 31st and for listeners who are in the US, that that has become probably, if not one of the largest holidays. I think Christmas is still the largest holiday celebrated in the United States. But I think Halloween is right there at second place. I think even displacing Thanksgiving or Fourth of July celebrations. At least in the sense of how much Americans spend on this holiday. And if you look at all the media that goes around it, whether that's movies or series that are associated with this kind of day of trying to scare one another or dress up in costumes. I mean, there's a more innocuous side of just going out and getting candy, which I think my kids were very interested in. Right? Could they get a pillowcase full of candy? It's kind of an appropriate question. And then, it wasn't this Sunday previous, but the one prior, we encountered a reading from Luke that spoke about the possession of a man by a legion of demons. And so the world of angels and demons is something that for those of us in the church is just real. And it's in our hymns. It's in our icons, it's in our prayers. It's in the lives of the saints. If you're reading the scriptures, the immaterial powers, both those aligned with God and those opposed to Him, are everywhere. Christ constantly is encountering those possessed. And here's the thing. We often don't think about this, but we don't actually think dispossession is a good thing. That's not really what the church is aiming at. So like when we think about the occult, in this case, this person who's a dear friend to a Christian who's beginning a life that is involved in the dark arts, whether it's trying to cast spells or read the future and just sort of starting to involve themselves in that. We would say, well, look, as a Christian, our role is not simply to be dispossessed of those things. Really the question is, what are we possessed by? And who are we possessed by? So Christians have always believed that the world was full of possession and you just wanted to make sure that you weren't possessed by the right wrong type of spirit. So I'm just pointing that out now for those who think and believe otherwise that there's no such thing as the immaterial world, right? No angels, no demons, no heaven, no hell, no spirits, nothing within the universe that's good and nothing that's evil. It's just science and matter and the material and loss of gravity and such. This conversation makes no sense. And increasingly that's the world that many people live in. Never ever was that the world our four parents lived in. They understood the world was filled with, if you will, something behind the veil. The universe is not just two-dimensional, right? It's three-dimensional. And really in St. Paul and in St. John and St. Peter and these sort of epistle writers, James, that world is present in their instructions to Christians, especially if you think about the writing of, let's say, St. John and the book of Revelation. He's really speaking from the point of view of how does this other world interact with ours and what does it do and what does it mean? And so, unfortunately, we have come to think that participating in evil and the forces of darkness as either a joke, right? In some cases, with the way that we treat Halloween, we sort of make evil a joke or we parody it or we get completely into it, right? In the case of this person who's moving into these things. Now, the sad thing is that evil, both in the representation that we have in Scripture and history and even still, I mean, I'm a pastor who, a priest who interacts with people who have been influenced by evil. It doesn't do good things. It wrecks lives, it destroys people. So the concern that this person has about their friend is well-placed. Being possessed by evil, participating in it isn't a joke. And the beginnings of one's entrance into the church begins with exorcism, right? That's the first thing we do. So if you want to be in the church, whether you're an infant or an adult, we read prayers of exorcism and then we claim you for Christ. And as you go through the service of baptism, you are clothed in Christ. You are possessed by the Spirit of God. That's what we do. And we even pray for it every time we start our prayers, you know, heavenly King, Comforter, Spirit of Truth, who are present everywhere and filling all things. Treasure your blessings and give our life. Come and abide in us. So what are we asking the Holy Spirit to do? To live in us, right? So that we're clothed in it. And this we know is beneficial, right? As opposed to trying to destroy us, it tries to bring life, you know, as opposed to isolating us, it brings us into communion. As opposed to seeking to destroy others and ourselves, it seeks to build up others. And even place us in a position of service to others. You know, evil doesn't serve. It manipulates. It dominates. So what is someone supposed to do when they are close friends with those who are now seeking to do the opposite? You know, and so she mentioned prayers as one of the things that she's doing. Absolutely, right? The other, as she mentioned, is inviting her to participate in the life of the church. And maybe that's not going to be initially a service like liturgy or Vespers or something else, complying or one of the other divine services, maybe, you know, just having them around your Christian community. That's been something I've seen be incredibly beneficial for people. Having them participate in some of the service or Christian activities that you're doing, right? Just seeing a different way of life. I had this guy show up at my church not long ago who said to me, father, I've come to understand that I'm going to have to wait to be baptized. But that's really hard for me. I would love to be baptized today. And I said, well, yeah, of course, I understand that. But tell me particularly why you would like to be baptized. And he said, well, because for years I participated in the occult. I was part of a group of Satanists and we held services and, you know, the things I did were unspeakable. And he said, just stepping into the church is a completely different experience of what life should mean and how it should be lived. So just giving people an opportunity to be around. And then I think the other thing you can do is to see about, you know, if you're close friends with somebody, it's just to discuss like the differing, you know, perspectives about what does evil bring, what does goodness bring, what does the demonic offer? What does the angelic offer? You know, what are the outcomes of both? What is possession by an evil spirit mean? Why would one seek it? You know, just some curiosity. And then, you know, that might lead to their curiosity about why you've chosen the life you have. And you let those ideas stand side by side and people will choose, right? At least they'll know what choice they're making. You know, so those are some ideas, you know, any thoughts on your end, Mike? I'm just kind of reminded of how sad it is in society sometimes to see, you know, this kind of behavior of desperately seeking some sense of enchantment in the world. Even if it is, like you said, even if it is something that's evil. And yeah, I'm also comforted by the many testimonies I've actually heard of people coming into the church, finding their way into the church because they were seeking that kind of charismatic, enchanted dimension to their spiritual practice. And they weren't even finding it in the flavor of Protestantism. They were in that was kind of like emphasizing that or, you know, not that it's any way equivalent, but then also, you know, yes, out and out, you know, witchcraft, Wicca folks. But God did work miracles in their lives to bring them to the church. And yeah, I don't know. I take comfort in that. Well, I think, too, you know, like some of the resources, like there's certainly books sold through ancient faith publishing on this topic. And there's that incredible podcast sort of spirits, right? Which is something that maybe you could ask your friend to listen to. I think that could be helpful. You know, another aspect of this is to think historically, you know, go back to a time in which nations were ruled by demons, as Saint Paul points out, you know, all the idols and all the worship of pagan society was worshipped to demons. I mean, Saint Paul is very clear in Corinthians about that. And, you know, what were those societies like? You know, we sort of mythologize what it would be like to be a Roman citizen or a citizen of Persia or ancient Greece. It's not good. I mean, they practice things that for us are unspeakable. You know, they did things that would land you not just in jail, but in the most, you know, largest supermax you can think of. And these are people that we think are great people like Plato or Socrates. You know, they practice ritual raping of children and and and spoke of being possessed themselves and, you know, killing a child, you know, or a husband in Roman society had complete authority over the lives of his household. Could do whatever he wanted. You know, we think about women's suffrage, you know, having the right to vote in, let's say, in the United States, which it's sad to think that at one point that right was denied. But go back in time and understand what those societies believed about women and how they were treated, let alone, you know, slavery. And not to say that we have our own terrible past with that. But, you know, just the way these societies were built, you know, you know, the idea of charities and hospices and feeding centers, I mean, that that doesn't exist. And and so, you know, we take for granted what Christianity did to the civilized world and how it brought about a new type of living. But the impact of moving from the worship of demons to the worship of God, the true God is palpable, even if today you're not a Christian. You know, we've completely refashioned what it means to be a human being because of the message of Christ and our allegiance to him and to his angels and to his dominion and to our position by the Holy Spirit. But all right, well, let's let's move on. Let's take our next question. All right. This next one comes from Ryan, who says, Hello, Father Evan. I have a question regarding the Eucharist. I know it's a central part of church life. If I never partake, will I go to hell? My wife is of deep Protestant background and isn't comfortable with herself or I drinking from the same spoon as other people. The tradition she comes from is that everyone received their own cup and piece of bread slash cracker. She is also on an immune system suppressing medication, which is another reason for her objections. Thank you, Ryan. Well, you know, there's several threads in this question. The first is, you know, is the Eucharist a part of our redemption, salvation, regeneration? And the answer is, Yeah, it is. Absolutely. We look at that, the reception of the Eucharist in that way. And there's all sorts of interesting ways in which we can view that either through scripture or the writings of saints within the church. But, you know, there is not a time in Christian history until late that, you know, we see that the Eucharist was not an absolute necessity, spiritually speaking. And it still is, right? That's not to say that either Christians and certainly non-Christians moved away from that practice, but the church still affirms that. Now, on the other side of that question, like, OK, so let's say someone never receives the Eucharist, will they be held out of the kingdom? Well, there's obvious examples in scripture of that not being the case. Right? Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, right? They didn't receive the Eucharist while on this in this life. The thief on the right hand of Christ, who was placed upon a cross, right? Did not receive the Eucharist. The prophets of old, right? And righteous men and women did not receive the Eucharist. But they do receive the Eucharist in a sense now. I mean, we understand that the Eucharist is, you know, what we participate here on earth is part of the heavenly banquet. And the Lord himself speaks about that in the end of Luke's gospel, you know, how he longs to eat this supper with them in which he's going to institute the mystical supper. And then he says, and how he will not eat it again until he eats it anew with them and his father's kingdom. So we represent that reality often at the back of our churches with the heavenly altar and Christ, the pure and mystical celebrant sort of language from Hebrews, who is then serving the Eucharist to the faithful. And, you know, we participated in this life. But is salvation possible for those who never received the Eucharist? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, the church is never going to put a roadblock in front of what God can do. And, you know, he's a perfect judge, as we say, merciful. And his understanding of our lives and circumstances even goes beyond our own. So in this person's case, if for whatever reasons deemed, you know, good and holy by God and they never received the Eucharist, well, the church wouldn't say, well, you can't be saved. But do we on the same time say, you know, the Eucharist is part of our salvation? Yes, absolutely. Right. Absolutely. And in the language of John 6 of 1 Corinthians 10, certainly the accounts that we find in the synoptics of the mystical supper, writings of the saints all affirm that. OK. Now, when it comes to the practice that some outside the church hold of sort of individual cups, often not even wine, but maybe just purified grape juice and, you know, a cracker or a sealed piece of bread. Keep in mind that this is a complete innovation, complete and total, you know, unheard of to the Christians of previous centuries. And, you know, these are Christians that lived in the midst of plagues, right, in every manner of sickness you can imagine. And never refrained from receiving the Eucharist and never has the Eucharist been a source of contagion or sickness, you know, which is a miracle, a wonder and a sign in of itself. I mean, as you probably know, my at the conclusion of a liturgy, the the celebrant goes and consumes the remainder of the chalice with the blood in it and then the body, right? So, you know, if if if the Eucharist was going to bring about physical illness because someone who had the flu or COVID or some other contagious sickness was to receive that day, then the priests would be continually ill. That doesn't mean you can't get ill from receiving the Eucharist. Saint Paul speaks about that, but that has to do with our preparation and our readiness spiritually. It doesn't have to do with whether or not germs are going into the chalice. And we have a recent experience of that, you know, COVID, where, you know, there was a very dangerous virus that spread across the world and brought sickness and death to many people and places, right? And my parish is one of many parishes, thousands of parishes that did not cease serving the liturgy and having people receive from the same chalice. And there are two reports of priests becoming sick from this. It just didn't occur, right? Now, what does that mean for someone, though, who's concerned or who's faith in or trust in this is weak? Well, the church doesn't sort of arm twist, you know, so I have people in my parish who are concerned and have, you know, in this case, this woman's taking a drug that suppresses their immune system. Others who have suppressed immune systems. And simple solution, I just tell them to come first, you know, come stand in line first if you're concerned and worried. You know, I have people who are caring for people who are very ill. And I'll tell them, stand apart in the church. If you need to mask even whatever precaution you need to take while being in a crowd, you know, take that precaution and then come first to the chalice. In extreme cases, we even can commune people outside of the liturgy. Right? That's done by priests all the time. Right? So there are ways that we address this pastorally, but it's not the norm nor nor is the church saying, well, the Eucharist isn't what we say it is. That's not what's going on there. It's just an allowance and a pastoral decision for the person. You know, it's not a new theology or a new dogma. Right? The other thing here is that, you know, there is this unspoken of difference here in the question. You know, the small cup with the purified grape juice and the wafer or the piece of bread and its own little sealed cup, there is no understandin