Devon Hase: Light Arose: A Talk on Freedom
This text has not been analysed yet.
Show the full text
So one morning, right about this time in the retreat, when I was in my three months, it was a morning a lot like we had today, where kind of a surprise early snow, first snow of the year. And my favorite routine on retreat is to come to the early morning sit, all dressed in my running clothes, and sit, but then go directly out for a run in the morning. And so I was doing that, and I ran the loop, and then I had this kind of secret way back through the woods, down through BCBS, and then up the hill, and really got a little bit of the woods, as I was coming back to the retreat center. And that particular morning, it was a lot like today, it was like this soft, very light snow, and the snowflakes were all like this very perfect New England crystals, you know, the way they get. And I don't know if this happened today, but it was a sunrise, and we could see the sunrise at the same time as the snow was falling. And so I was running on the trail, up through the woods, and the sun was coming, and there were these layers of orange and purple and blue in the sky, and the sun was coming through golden, and all the little crystals were lighting up with rainbows as they fell in the trees. And then I had to stop running because it was like everything was rainbow. And I was a rainbow, and the whole world was sparkly, and I was like in a Buddha realm, and I was a Buddha! I was like crying. So beautiful, just the sense of like, oh. And I had an interview with Joseph that morning, and I went in describing it to him a lot like I just did for you. And I said, Joseph, I know it's so hard to explain, it sounds banal, but it really was enlightenment. Joseph was so sweet. He looked at me and his eyes all lit up, and he's like, I believe you. So that's what I want to talk about freedom tonight. And in that moment, freedom for me had something to do with beauty and with peace. And then with this sense, it was so much, my being couldn't hold it, and there was this sense of offering, giving it away, giving back to Joseph. So you might even consider, as I talk about freedom, how do you experience freedom? What is freedom for you? And I'll use a lot of words that the Buddha used, but a big invitation to make this your own. How does your heart-mind experience freedom? What do you already know about getting free? So last week, we did the first Noble Truth of Dukka, and this evening we'll do the third Noble Truth of freedom. And this is how it goes in the Sutta, same Sutta, Dhamma Chakapawatana Sutta. Irangopana Bhikhawe Dukkha Nerorangari Asachang Yotasaewatana Ya Asesawiragani Rodam Chakapatti Nisagomutti Analayo Now this yogis is the Noble Truth of the cessation of suffering. It is the remainderless fading away and cessation of that same craving, the giving up and relinquishing of it, freedom from it, non-reliance on it. So this third Noble Truth is often translated as the cessation, cessation of suffering, Dukkha Nerorang. So it sounds like an ending, it sounds kind of like harsh. You can notice how does this word land for you, cessation. Maybe it's inspiring, maybe it's a little like, I don't know, is that what I want? But it's said in the Pallium specific, it's the end of that same craving that we've been talking about, the Dukkha. Joseph talked about craving. So it's the end of that same craving, we've been experiencing Dukkha arising and now the Buddha's like, and its ceases, whatever arises will also pass away. If Dukkha has a cause, if Dukkha has an arising, it also has a passing away. And so that's the good news that's embedded even in the second, the first and second Noble Truth, it's all about Dukkha Dukkha. It's like, no, there's good news right in there. And this is the key to the insight, whatever arises also passes away. So I want to use some of these Polly words because they're beautiful, these terms. So maybe you've heard them, they come a lot, this sequence. So, we raga, we raga. The literal meaning of this word, we raga, is color draining out of a cloth. So you might imagine it's like color draining away, right, this fading, this fading out. Sometimes we raga is translated as dispassion, but I like the image of like a cloth that's been dyed and that dye is kind of washing out, getting back to its natural state. And this dispassion, this fading away, we experience this, I think in very subtle ways in retreat. It's hard to see. A lot of these words are in the via negativa, right, v raga, dispassion, not the dye but the fading out of it. So it's hard to see how your raga has been fading through your practice. But when you go home, you might notice, you might notice some things. And one way I like to experience this is, you know, we've been out of, coming out of retreat and there's all the integration and like Nakaway was talking about last night. There's the drama of airports and grocery stores and the colors and the movement of the world. But then notice this is your assignment. Don't think about going home yet, but when you do, your assignment is to step into your place, apartment, whatever, your house and to really look around and to notice what happens. Because for me, often it's like I'm walking into somebody else's place. And there's a sense of like, oh, I actually really like the person who lives here. Like, good tasting clothes, you know. I would have chosen all those clothes and I like the paintings, you know. I would have chosen those paintings. But there's a like, it's a v raga. There's like less owning it and so there's less entanglement in it. There's a space of like, I like that person, but I kind of like, I'm a little bit less of that person now. And that lightness makes home even better. Right? It's like a new way to be in our home with fresh eyes. So you might notice even just now if you turn to your mind, how are you feeling that fading out, remainderless, kind of fading out of the dye in your mind, a kind of dispassion, a quiet, a quiet lessening. And we're learning to look for what's absent. So it's tuning your view in a different way, not what's present, what's absent. When is craving absent and how does that feel? How does that feel in your mind? So we've got v raga and then we've got niroda. Another word in the negative, right? Niroda. I was emailing some with Gil Fransdahl. This is like his territory. Gil loves to talk about this. We raga niroda. So he translates, he was saying, it's really interesting this word niroda, the etymology, ní means without and roda means an obstacle. So niroda is without obstacle. Sometimes Joseph likes to translate this as a mind with no edges. And how would that feel? I mean, what's beautiful is that I can feel it in the room now. You know, we all have our kind of personal edges for sure. But there is a kind of collective mind, a kind of sangha mind that feels pretty smooth and pretty free of edges. That just might be my projection, but you might feel it, right? Your mind without edges. So some of you know that Nico and I spent many years, several years, 2020 to 2023 in a long cabin retreat. And we went to see our teacher Ming-Gi-Rinpoche after coming out. And we kind of shot out of our retreat like cannonballs. We like bought a van, we drove across the country, went to visit all these friends. And part of the stop along the way was going to see Ming-Gi-Rinpoche in person who had been guiding us along with Joseph and other teachers. And Ming-Gi-Rinpoche has this like endless well of energy and he teaches all the time, travels the world, gets up very, very early, does his practice, and has all these meetings and all the dinners with fundraisers and then spends two or three hours on into the evening making YouTube videos. Like he's just very busy, just enlightened activity happening. And so we asked him, you know, Ming-Poche, do you get tired? Like how is this for you to hold such a busy international teaching schedule? And it was great. It was sort of like he was stumped by that question. And he's like, yeah, I'm busy. I'm really busy. And I'm not really tired. He's like, hmm, you know, how is it? And his description was really very based on altruism, he said. It's because I get enormous energy from helping people and I feel that I am helping people. I believe in what I'm doing and so there's this sense of a mind without obstacle. Right? And I know enough about his life and his organization that he runs and all of the people that he is, you know, managing to know there are obstacles there. It's like complex, a lot of humans together. But the way Ming-Poche phrases it is that these obstacles are opportunities. And that's one way that we're transmuting, you know, rather than seeing the obstacles. And it's been beautiful to hear you about your practice because when we recognize the hindrance for what it is, it's no longer a hindrance and this is happening for you in your practice. It's like, you know, the edges become illusory, how it feels to be without obstacle. Gil's translation, you know, mind without obstacle, neurota, he likes to use the more colloquial sense of peace. It's pretty peaceful. You can sense into that. And then Chaga, Pati Nisega, kind of a combo. Chaga is the everyday use of generosity. So you hear dana as generosity as kind of a more formal dharma term. But Chaga is just this like everyday kind of offering, you know, giving something, open-handedness. So Pati Nisega, Chaga, it's a kind of giving away, which is translated as relinquishment. But I really love that this sense of like, it's relinquishment is generous, right? Sometimes we get afraid because there's like all this emphasis on renunciation and like, what do I have then in Switzerland go of? But what if it was actually offering, offering, offering, and how could that feel to offer? You know, that's a few who have been offering the meals to our venerable, right? Many are both of our venerables. Doesn't it feel so good? It feels so good. So what if we were just like making ourselves, making of ourselves and offering? So many stories I have about my own resistance to generosity and then how I've overcome that. In that moment of all the rainbows in the woods, it was so overwhelming that I did have to just sort of imagine like, okay, I'm not making each snowflake as an offering to the world, you know, each rainbow, each moment of beauty and offering, offering. And then years later, I, so for like 20 years, I had my favorite meditation shawl that looked a lot like this one. But it came from Sikkim in India, my first pilgrimage there when I was 20. And I stayed in a monastery there during big prayer festivals and stuff. And there was this one younger monk who I was hanging out with some and kind of had a crush on this monk. But the positive romance, nothing happened, I promise. But he was also very kind. And so at the end of the week of prayer festivals, he gave me his shawl, his meditation shawl. And so I had just like carried it and traveled with it and practiced with it and took it on all of my long retreats and had lived in the mountains of Colorado in a retreat center for years with that shawl and practiced in a yurt that had a pack rat. And that pack rat really loved chewing on the shawl. And so there were like, you know, little nibbles and it was kind of ragged on one side and stained and like just so beloved as pack rat like used the shreds to create this whole nest. It was like many stories embedded in this shawl. And then we were in our teacher training down at BCBS and to where he came up and she's like, oh, that shawl is so nice. Can I see it? She sort of like put it on. She's like, it's just nice. It's big. You know, it fits. And I looked at her and I was like, oh no, I think I have to give her my shawl. She looked so good in it. And so he did it. Like I had a pause. I had to think about it. It was a little resistant. And then I really like did it with some mindfulness. I was like, your shawl, please come and my shawl. And it was such a humble offer. He was like all tattered and worn, you know. He so graciously received it. It was this precious thing. And so for a while honestly as I kept practicing I really missed it. Like, oh man, my shawl. But then I would think about it as to where he was traveling and teaching and wearing the shawl. And immediately my mind got happy. She's blessing it, you know, by teaching in it. And that's often, you know, our trajectory of practice is it's hard to give things up. It's hard to give up. It's hard to relinquish who we think we are. It's hard to relinquish our idea of practice, of what it should be, how it's unfolding. It's hard to relinquish the vision we have of Samadhi, you know, when we had Samadhi years ago and now we don't anymore. It's like... But it's giving away, right? It's like another thing we can offer. So how is it for you there's a lot of good practice now in this room? How is it to imagine offering all your practice? Give it away. Nothing to hold on to. Again, offering for the world. And how does your heart feel when you do that? I mean you get to give away all the struggle too. I give away all the beauty. It's freely offered. There's some freedom there maybe, some chagga. And then this last word, I learned something today about it, analia. So we have our lovely German scholar, Monk Analia, down at BCVS. But this word, analia is another via negativa. So alaya means a dwelling. So himalaya means the land of snows, right? The place for snow, himalaya. But analia means no dwelling place, no abode. And the image is like a bird without a perch or a bird without a nest. And I was thinking about that. I was like so much of practice for me actually feels like coming home. You know, it feels like finding home. Sometimes the image is like we're a land dwelling bird that has been lost at sea. And then we take refuge and we come home. But in analia, it's the opposite. It's like your nest is a little bit smelly. You know, it's your smelly nest. Like the way that we kind of like make ourselves all kind of comfortable with our costume and our ego and our mask and all this stuff. And when we let go of that, there's no place to land. And that is our true home. There's no bird, no perch, no nest, just free, right? Nothing to lean on, no leaning. Nobody to lean. That's what analia means. And so finding our true home in this emptiness, finding our true home in freedom, in peace, in real inquisiment. And one way that we can experience this, I've been noticing in my own mind there's this habit, my particular personality habit, maybe it's because I'm an only child. I've always had like close girlfriends who I secretly resented. Like, I love you so much, but you're really annoying too. You know, and I have these like little things like, you just be a little different this way. Or, you know, and it's funny, it sort of like occupies some real estate in my mind. This like love, hate kind of frenemy experience that I have often. But usually that's perception. That is a mistaken perception. Just like Naka Wei was talking about last night, we have this like thread and then we spin this whole story. And I like to really think a lot about my friends in retreat in particular. So I have these perceptions, these stories that are spinning about like, but she was just a little bit better this way. Or like, you know, this and that would be better. And I have this whole kind of perceptive story. But a little bit like coming home and feeling different. When I actually see that friend, that perception is so obviously diluted. I'm just seeing one side of it. And the person in 3D, with all of their dimensions and all their angles, it's like powerful enough to break through all of my mistaken perceptions, my resentments, my little ways of like, I just love you better if you did this. No, it's like this person here and I love you, you know. That's that sense of like, the mind likes to land in this territory of a little bit of dissatisfaction. But if I really like take in the reality of these friendships, there's no place for that resentment to land. There's nothing to land on. And so it's released. It's free. So the Buddha says, you know, with these words, this fading out, this peace, this relinquishment, as no place to land, he says this is what's to be realized. This freedom is to be realized. And there's this beautiful passage that's repeated 12 times in the same sutra, where he's describing the experience of what it felt like to truly realize this third noble truth of freedom. And so it goes like this. Pube ananusutesudamesu Cakung udapadi, nyanang udapadi Panya udapadi, vicha udapadi Aloko udapadi There's really fun words to pronounce, you know. Cakung udapadi, nyanang udapadi Panya udapadi, vicha udapadi Aloko udapadi So it's this realization about things never heard before, never known before. There arose vision, knowledge, wisdom, and light. All those nyanyanyas, the Nakawee was saying, nyanyang, wisdom, knowledge about things never heard before. So you can feel this freshness. You know, this was a discovery that the Buddha made. It wasn't what he learned from somebody else. It wasn't a text that he read. There was this like in the moment, oh never, never heard before. I'm seeing it newly. It's like Nakawee was like, he was a genius. He figured this out. And you have this image of him as he's describing it. Right? About things never heard before. There arose vision. And this arising, this is, I think I was talking about it two weeks ago, that it's not something we make happen. Right? That there's this kind of like blessing or this, it's so anata. It comes from somewhere else. And you've had this experience, I know, when you have an insight, you're like, where did that come from? I didn't, you were sort of like here working away, tilling the soil, figuring out the conditions. But actually when it happens, it's like not so obviously not us. Like all the rainbows in the forest. So it comes when the conditions are right, we don't make it happen. So there arose vision, knowledge, wisdom and light. Another image that we can use, maybe you saw the crescent moon hanging in the sky over the horizon, that it's like this freedom that the Buddha experienced is like the moon being freed from clouds. Because when we have insight, I mean all this imagery and language around seeing, vision, sight, see something new, right? That it's, there's luminosity there. Right? Like the light of the moon. There's a shining. There's a brightness. And we feel that the kind of shining of our minds, of our hearts as we're practicing. You don't get to see this, but we get to see you. We get to look at you in these meetings and you're shining. It's real. There is a kind of glow. And that's that Chakun Udipati, the aloko Udipati that is happening. That's luminosity that's coming. So the Buddha gives this whole teaching. He describes, you know, I saw this and I saw this, like new seeing, right? About things never seen before. And he's teaching his five friends. And the last passage in the Sutta is beautiful because it goes to Kondanya, who's the first one to see this. And it says, Kondanya saw whatever the, has the nature of arising, has the nature of passing away. And the particular Pali, the language has an exclamation point in it. So I don't know how they know that with the punctuation, but there's in the language itself this exclamation that Kondanya says, oh my gosh, whatever arises also passes away. Wow, exclamation point, exclamation point, exclamation point. He has this light that comes and the Buddha recognizes it and he has that joy. The Mudita we were practicing this afternoon. And he's so happy for Kondanya. He says, Kondanya sees, Kondanya sees, he's understood. And that is when the wheel of the Dhamma begins rolling. And you feel it. I love this image of the wheel of the Dhamma rolling because it's this lineage, right? It's getting passed along. It's not like a thing yet, right? The Buddha just saw