Not Every Act of Kindness Is a Mitzvah | 10@9 | 2026.11.13
This text has not been analysed yet.
Show the full text
Good morning. Today is Friday, November 13, 2026. I heard this story from Rabbi David Lau from when he was Ashkenazi chief Rabbi of Israel. He was flying from Toronto back to Israel. He was at the airport and he was approached by a religious HaRadi man who said to him, Rav Lau, please do a chesed for me, a kindness, I need a favor. I have an extra suitcase. I'm going to be charged a lot for it. I see that you're traveling light. Please check my suitcase together with yours under your name. And then when we get to Israel, I'll take it. So Rabbi Lau said to him, I'm very sorry, I would like to help you. But number one, I don't know you. And number two, I don't know what's inside the suitcase. So I can't do that because we all go through Israeli security. They will ask me, did I pack this myself? Do I know everything that's inside for security reasons? And I won't be able to answer them. The man said, oh no, but that's why you're perfect to do this favor for me. Because you're the chief Rabbi of Israel. You're a member of the government. You're a VIP. They wouldn't dare open your suitcase. And Rabbi Lau said, my friend, it's exactly the opposite. They will specifically open my suitcases to try to see if they can catch a VIP. A member of the government. A respected Rabbi. Not following the rules. And if they do find something that I didn't pack, it will be a terrible Khilashem, a desegration of God's name. It's not just me who will get in trouble, but it will cause shame to every Rabbi and every religious Jew. So this man says to him, so what you're telling me Rabbi Lau, chief Rabbi Lau, is that you're not willing to do a chesed to help another Jew. And Rabbi Lau said to him, I do want to do a chesed. I do want to do a kindness for another Jew. But this is not a chesed. This is something that is low yashar. It's not straight. It's not honest. And if it's not yashar, it's not a chesed. Rabbi Naphtali Tsvi Hirsch Berlin was an important scholar and teacher in Eastern Europe in the 1800s. I've quoted him to you many times. He wrote many important works, including a commentary to the Torah called Haamei Dabar. And he writes a psicha, a foreword to the book of Bureshes. And it's one page. It's classic. Everyone should know this. And I share part of it with you today. He writes Zahe Saffer and Nikra Saffer Bureshes. This book, the first of the five books of the Torah, which we call the Book of Bureshes. Nikra Bipei and Aviam Saffer Hayashar. It is called by the prophets in several of the different books of prophecy, Saffer Hayashar. The Book of the Straight or the Book of the Upright. Viash Lehavit, and we have to understand. Why is it called this? Why is it not called the Book of the Righteous or the Book of the Pious? But rather, Saffer Hayashar, the Book of the Upright, the Book of the Straight. Why is that? And he explains that this quality of Yashar means as follows. To give one example, when our sages wanted to explain how could it be that God caused the destruction of the base of Miktosh, the second base of Miktosh, the Holy Temple, and the fact that at the time of that destruction, there were many great people. There were Tzadikim. There were righteous people. There were Chassidim. There were pious people there. Achlohayu yusharim bahalikos olim. But they were not upstanding people. They were not straight. As our sages tell us, they engaged in synazkinim, in needless hatred. They might have made brokhos. They might have put on tfilim. They might have kept shabbas carefully. But they were not yashar. They were not upstanding, upright people, straight people with each other. Vizah yishvah haavos. And this is the praise of our patriarchs and our matriarchs. Shemilvah chayu tzadikim vechassidim ve'o avayashem ve'ofan hayosar e'eshar. Not only were they righteous and pious and lovers of God to an extent that is as much as possible. O'd but furthermore, hayu yusharim, they were straight. They were upright. Hainush shiiznago im umos olim afilu ovde alilim muhu'arim. They treated every person with respect. They were straight. They were honest with every single person. Even with people whose religious beliefs they completely rejected. Mikomakam hayu imam ba'ahavah. Still they dealt with them with love. Vechashu letovahsum. And they wanted their well-being. They wanted them to be okay. Ba'ashar heki imabriah. Because this is what keeps the world going. They were not only concerned with themselves. They were not only concerned with their own piety and righteousness. They were concerned with the well-being of everyone. And they had respect for everyone. They treated everyone with honesty and with respect and with dignity. As we see, the extent to which Avram went to pray for to save the people of Sadom. Sadom, the people who were so... So the opposite of his own values. And yet he cared about them. He hated their behaviors. But he cared about them as people. And he wanted them to survive. And so he negotiated with God on their behalf. Arabis in the Medres say that God said to Avram, Ahavahsedek vatinase resha. Which means, Ahavahs lahatsik esbryasi. I want you to love helping my creatures. My creations, God says. Human beings. Vatinase laharsian. And you should hate to have to do anything that would harm them. You should hate that. Bahaynum mamish kaav hamungaim. This is exactly what is the reason that God gives for changing Avram's name from Avram to Avraham. We discussed this before. Because his perspective was not only to look out for himself and his family. But Avhamungaim, he was a father to every single human being. She afal gav sheayin haben holaik be mey shorim. Even when a parent has a child, that is not following the path that they want them to follow. Mekom makom shochher shlomo vatovoh. Always a parent wants what's best for the child. The well-being of the child. That the child should be okay. Regardless of the behavior. We see this. Kamenakhaya yitzchak avinulis payes mimisanov. Ubim ad divray piis bavim elekh. When Yitzchak was arguing with Avim elekh. We see how much Yitzchak wanted to bring peace and wanted to appease. And was willing to give in and to compromise. We find by Yakov. We will see this soon in the Torah. Achashahetiv haral loa lavan. When his father-in-law had mistreated him so terribly. Over years and years and cheated him and mistreated him. Mekom makom diva emo diva aram rakim. Still Yakov spoke to him with respect. Vinis payes emo. And came to agreement with him. And negotiated with him. And I would just add in our Torah portion this weekend. We spoke about this last night. When Yakov did act in a deceitful manner towards his father. He paid a price for it. The Torah tells us Yakov suffered because of it. Yes, of course, there are reasons that Yakov did it. Yes, of course, there is a recitalization. His mother told him to do it. Okay, whatever that discussion is. But he paid a price for it. He suffered because of it. Because it was not Yashar. And we learned so much from the way our patriarchs and matriarchs Bader Cherec to treat others properly. To be honest. To be straightforward. Not to mislead. To be respectful. And now we well understand why this book is called Safer HaYashar. The book of the upstanding. The book of the straight. The book of the respectful. Shuhu Safer Habriah. This is the basis on which the world is created. If something is not Yashar, it's not a chesed. If something is not Yashar, it's not a mitzvah. And we should strive in every area of our lives to not only be a tzadik, to not only be a chesed, but to be a Yashar. My friends, I wish you a great day and a beautiful Shabbos. And I look forward to seeing you soon in person.